Serial Killers, A pattern???

[corey123]

You said 'Ripperologists of repute' not posters on a JtR forum. Making a sweeping statement like that is part of the problem with this website. Not one single person on these forums has ever come up with a reasonable reason to exclude Mary Kelly as one of the C5. And every book of repute written on the subject includes her.

Having a theory and posting it on a forum is one thing, being a 'reputable' Ripperologist remains the territory of messers Begg & Co'.

There are alot of expert Ripperologist that post here. Steward P. Evans as an example.

[corey123]

David,

Dunno. I see a right handed killer through out the murders.

[Sox]

Hello Sox,

Respectfully, I advise you to read through the threads, You will find them there.

best wishes and a Happy New Year!

Phil

You said 'Ripperologists of repute' not posters on a JtR forum. Making a sweeping statement like that is part of the problem with this website. Not one single person on these forums has ever come up with a reasonable reason to exclude Mary Kelly as one of the C5. And every book of repute written on the subject includes her.

Having a theory and posting it on a forum is one thing, being a 'reputable' Ripperologist remains the territory of messers Begg & Co'.

[DVV]

David,

I agree.

Now the remaining question is: why do people want Jack to be left-handed ?

Amitiés
David

[DVV]

Mike,

I liked answering them.

I would say it would be wrong to say the killer of Nichols to be left handed, for one Llewllyn isnt very credable. He says he thinks she was killed while standing up, He thinks the killer to be left handed, he even thought the abdominal wounds came first befor the cut throat. He even later doubted his theory of a left handed killer.

yours truly.

p.s yes I know that a theory is only but a theory.

You've been warned, Corey.
Now show your beard.

[corey123]

David,

I agree.

[DVV]

Hi corey,

I appreciate the answers you provided,... I will just add though in one Canonical case its almost certain the killer was left handed. Best regards corey

Hi Mike,

you mean in Nichols' case ??
Good Heavens!
Even Llewellyn changed his mind, and that is certain, not almost.

Amitiés mon cher,
David

[corey123]

Mike,

I liked answering them.

I would say it would be wrong to say the killer of Nichols to be left handed, for one Llewllyn isnt very credable. He says he thinks she was killed while standing up, He thinks the killer to be left handed, he even thought the abdominal wounds came first befor the cut throat. He even later doubted his theory of a left handed killer.

yours truly.

p.s yes I know that a theory is only but a theory.

Hi corey,

I appreciate the answers you provided,... I will just add though in one Canonical case its almost certain the killer was left handed. Rather than belabor the point, Ill let you and David and others carry on with this line of questioning as I know you're serious in your quest to find proof for your theory.

Again, bearing in mind that "theory" is just an opinion without facts to validate it.

That's why I and others contest a Canonical Group in the first place.

Good luck, see you on other threads Im sure.

Best regards corey

[Phil Carter]

Hello Sox,

Respectfully, I advise you to read through the threads, You will find them there.

best wishes and a Happy New Year!

Phil

[corey123]

Take away repute and you get Mike, Lynn, and Phil(dont know them enough to say if they are of repute so no offense ment)

[Sox]

Kelly is also under question, by established Ripperologists of repute.

Name three 'Ripperologists of repute' who question Kelly as one of the C5.

[corey123]

well,

I am really tipsy on the stride topic. Right now Im for her
being a victim but barely so.

Anyways I could say he was interupted as still find that constent trait.

yours truly

[Phil Carter]

And yes those three are, but you asked and I told you a constent trait.
Ok, to be a good sport, heres another.
Lets discard stride for a moment, another constent trait it disembowlment.

Hello Corey,

On the Battleground thread, you have voted for ONE killer of SIX victims.
Either Stride is in or out. It has nothing to do with sporting behaviour to offer to drop Stride, just to fit another catagory!

Respectfully

best wishes

Phil

[DVV]

Well no because I have no clue what or where it is???

Thus be there at 6.
The Calypso.
Front de Mer.
You can't miss it.