Bible John: A New Suspect by Jill Bavin-Mizzi

[New Waterloo]

Herlocks suggestion is very good because it follows pieces of evidence that are very strong. Dishevelled man on bus, used to stay with relatives close to bus stop. McInnes confident and forward in his communication. Able to convince people of his alibi.

I like it because it gives a narrative linking facts and not as in my case suggesting something without being able to substantiate it.

Herlocks suggestion (at the moment) is as good as we are going to get proving its McInnes. To me Jeannie the star witness muddies the water. I find her evidence a bit ambiguous and confused if they are the right words to use. It could be as Herlock suggested the alcohol clouding her memory which is a shame really if that was the case (although not criticising her for having a drink).

NW

[Herlock Sholmes]

Herlocks suggestion is very good because it follows pieces of evidence that are very strong. Dishevelled man on bus, used to stay with relatives close to bus stop. McInnes confident and forward in his communication. Able to convince people of his alibi.

I like it because it gives a narrative linking facts and not as in my case suggesting something without being able to substantiate it.

Herlocks suggestion (at the moment) is as good as we are going to get proving its McInnes. To me Jeannie the star witness muddies the water. I find her evidence a bit ambiguous and confused if they are the right words to use. It could be as Herlock suggested the alcohol clouding her memory which is a shame really if that was the case (although not criticising her for having a drink).

NW

Hi NW,

I certainly have no qualms about corruption or cover ups but I just can’t see Beattie covering for a man that he knew (or suspected) had killed three women. Maybe he did…I’m certainly not saying that I’m right…it’s just that I can’t help having doubts. This case appeared to obsess Beattie to some extent. Did he agree to covering up the identity of a man that he genuinely believed innocent at the time but he later came to realise that he’d been conned and that he’d been guilty all along? And a guy that he considered his close friend had basically stitched him up. Such a realisation would have had a real effect on a man who prided himself on his ability to judge people and to spot a ‘wrong ‘un’ a mile off.