John Richardson

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • FISHY1118
    *
    • May 2019
    • 3607

    #2671
    Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post

    Absolutely no!

    The witnesses are not ambiguous in the slightest. Cadosch said that he definitely heard a noise coming from the yard of number 29. Richardson said that he definitely couldn’t have missed a body had it been there. These are the opposite of ambiguous. You are confusing the word ‘ambiguous’ with the word ‘imperfect.’

    We cannot assess Phillips so he has to be sidelined. But we certainly can and should assess the witnesses. If we applied your criteria Fishy no case would ever get solved because only perfect witnesses would be considered. I can’t think of a single perfect witness in this case. So do we just stop discussing the case?

    Phillips and the witnesses are separate issues and cannot be treated the same.
    Absolutly yes . its all been discussed befor, its over, just as trevor suggested . The witnesses are in the same boat as phillips .

    t.o.d. is no certainty in either case . Thats been proven pretty much so i reckon

    Comment

    • FISHY1118
      *
      • May 2019
      • 3607

      #2672
      Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post

      It is indeed Game Over on Phillips. The witnesses are separate matter.
      Your the only one who thinks that . Yes indeed they are . Georges post 1320 put that to bed . . Same result everytime ones looks at it .

      Comment

      • FISHY1118
        *
        • May 2019
        • 3607

        #2673
        Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post

        I prefer the truth to diplomacy.
        NO you prefer ignorance and lack diplomacy, unlike trevor who at least tried .

        Comment

        • Herlock Sholmes
          Commissioner
          • May 2017
          • 21802

          #2674
          Originally posted by FISHY1118 View Post

          Absolutly yes . its all been discussed befor, its over, just as trevor suggested . The witnesses are in the same boat as phillips .

          t.o.d. is no certainty in either case . Thats been proven pretty much so i reckon
          It’s impossible to argue with poor reasoning like this.
          Regards

          Sir Herlock Sholmes.

          “A house of delusions is cheap to build but draughty to live in.”

          Comment

          • FISHY1118
            *
            • May 2019
            • 3607

            #2675
            Only a monumental fool would believe 3 witnesses couldnt either have lied ,been mistaken , embellished their testimony etc, etc,. its only been done like a thousand times over history . Odds have nothing to do with it .

            Comment

            • FISHY1118
              *
              • May 2019
              • 3607

              #2676
              Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post

              It’s impossible to argue with poor reasoning like this.
              Yes indeed we all feel the same way about you too .

              Comment

              • Herlock Sholmes
                Commissioner
                • May 2017
                • 21802

                #2677
                Originally posted by FISHY1118 View Post

                Your the only one who thinks that . Yes indeed they are . Georges post 1320 put that to bed . . Same result everytime ones looks at it .
                Apparently I’m not because 94% of posters in the last, and quite recent poll, favoured the witnesses.

                To say that the Doctors TOD and the witnesses are in the same boat is simply a deliberate ploy to close down a debate. I don’t mind if debate ends. Witnesses over the Doctor to anyone with even a scintilla of reason.
                Regards

                Sir Herlock Sholmes.

                “A house of delusions is cheap to build but draughty to live in.”

                Comment

                • Herlock Sholmes
                  Commissioner
                  • May 2017
                  • 21802

                  #2678
                  Originally posted by FISHY1118 View Post

                  Yes indeed we all feel the same way about you too .
                  And the 94% of posters who favour the witnesses.
                  Regards

                  Sir Herlock Sholmes.

                  “A house of delusions is cheap to build but draughty to live in.”

                  Comment

                  • Herlock Sholmes
                    Commissioner
                    • May 2017
                    • 21802

                    #2679
                    Ok, Fishy is going into babyish, fingers-in-the-ear comment mode. No point in even attempting reasoned debate d sadly.
                    Regards

                    Sir Herlock Sholmes.

                    “A house of delusions is cheap to build but draughty to live in.”

                    Comment

                    • FISHY1118
                      *
                      • May 2019
                      • 3607

                      #2680
                      SO do you want to keep going or maybe you should just except Trevors post ? you know the one where were all aloud to have a different opinion and disagree . Then we can all move on . Everyone else has .

                      Comment

                      • FISHY1118
                        *
                        • May 2019
                        • 3607

                        #2681
                        What ever herlock .

                        Comment

                        • FISHY1118
                          *
                          • May 2019
                          • 3607

                          #2682
                          Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post

                          And the 94% of posters who favour the witnesses.
                          Where , in that poll ?

                          Comment

                          • FISHY1118
                            *
                            • May 2019
                            • 3607

                            #2683
                            Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post
                            Ok, Fishy is going into babyish, fingers-in-the-ear comment mode. No point in even attempting reasoned debate d sadly.
                            Is that the same as herlock ''stomping his feet mode'' as trevor and george have suggested ?

                            Comment

                            • GBinOz
                              Assistant Commissioner
                              • Jun 2021
                              • 3005

                              #2684
                              Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes View Post

                              Apparently I’m not because 94% of posters in the last, and quite recent poll, favoured the witnesses.

                              To say that the Doctors TOD and the witnesses are in the same boat is simply a deliberate ploy to close down a debate. I don’t mind if debate ends. Witnesses over the Doctor to anyone with even a scintilla of reason.
                              Herlock,

                              EVERYONE is by now very well aware of your opinions. NOONE wants another recitation of those opinions with your apparently obligatory insulting conclusion. You have drawn your conclusions, others have drawn theirs. Anyone with even a scintilla of reason will accept that fact graciously.

                              Cheers, George

                              Comment

                              • GBinOz
                                Assistant Commissioner
                                • Jun 2021
                                • 3005

                                #2685
                                Originally posted by Fleetwood Mac View Post

                                Not all of us. I believe Annie was murdered closer to 2.30am than 5.30am. I think George is in agreement with this.
                                Hi FM,

                                Yes, that would be my considered opinion. Others are free to disagree, and that is their prerogative.

                                Cheers, George

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X