Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes
View Post
She supposedly went onto her doorstep at 12.45.
But she said just after Smith passed.
Smith said that he passed at 12.30-12.35.
Can we say that Smith was definitely accurate on time….no.
Can we say that Fanny was definitely accurate on time…..no.
Can we say that Schwartz was definitely accurate on time….no.
But she said just after Smith passed.
Smith said that he passed at 12.30-12.35.
Can we say that Smith was definitely accurate on time….no.
Can we say that Fanny was definitely accurate on time…..no.
Can we say that Schwartz was definitely accurate on time….no.
However, sticking with 12:48 raises a number of issues, other than that you're now starting to sound a bit like MWR. Goldstein was seen just before Fanny turned in, so we could make that 12:43, to fit the scenario. I think it is fair to say there is about 5 minutes of blood flow, by the time Louis is observing the victim by candlelight. That would place the murder at very close to 12:43 - right when Goldstein should be hurrying by toward Fairclough street. So that means Goldstein should have seen Stride standing in the gateway, right before she died, but apparently he said nothing about this. Is that because Schwartz lied, or was it because...?
He might ha' been coming from the Socialist Club.
The other big issue is that Schwartz is now arriving, after the murder.
And so I’ll say for the 1000th time, Fanny Mortimer cannot be used to prove that Schwartz wasn’t there. And that’s a fact.
Comment