In the name of honesty...

[Tom_Wescott]

Thanks, Monty. Yes, I remember the Gill thread now. AP posted all about it. The kid was torn to pieces.

Sounds like this is a ruckus between AP and Silverstealth. Since nobody outside of this thread has heard of the Gill murder, I can't imagine AP's posting about it will hurt the sales of Silver's book. But at the same time, I completely understand Silver's concerns and I empathize with him.

Yours truly,

Tom Wescott

[Jenni Shelden]

Hi,

my brain really hurts now. Can we go back to discussing something important, like say....cheese
?

Jenni

[Nurse Sarah]

Too late Ally, the wine is flowing a la maison!

[Ally]

If the information was already in public domain and AP has already posted about it previously, then it would seem wise for him to point to that information so as to save Silver the embarrassment of publishing something he thinks is groundbreaking only to discover it is not.

I don't understand why he's railing at Silver for not publishing something and getting the truth out there, if it's ALREADY out there??

This is why people shouldn't drink. This kind of thing could however, lead them to start!

[Cap'n Jack]

And, Silver, I still offer you my full support and encouragement to publish your findings, although I would also encourage you to publish them here on the message boards.
Trouble is I think you will find that they have already been published more than a hundred years ago.
No matter though. I don't think I would ever post private messages that you sent to me, simply because I regard them as intrinsically private, so I think you broke the code of honour before I did.
You sacrificied a ear.
Honour is done, I am no longer in your debt.

[Nurse Sarah]

Nice one Silver!

Now thats 'honest'....in all its brutality...

[silverstealth]

Deleted

[Natalie Severn]

Debs you are a star!

[Debra A]

I'm just posting in the name of honesty, that's the thread title. There's someone else not being entirely truthful on here and it's not AP.

[Robert]

I'll give AP a character reference. As for Gill, I don't have a sodding clue what it's all about. Bradford's a bit off the beaten track for me, and it's grim up north.

[Monty]

Tom,

The young lad, name of Gill, murdered in Bradford..,..do keep up.

Monty

[babybird67]

if that's true..

and the information is already in the public domain, what's the problem????

[Tom_Wescott]

I see. I'm having a brainfart at the moment. Could someone remind me what the Gill murder is?

Yours truly,

Tom Wescott

[Debra A]

He's being gagged about posting details of the Gill murder, supposedly only recently found and needed for a book. But he did know these details before, and has posted about them.

[Nurse Sarah]

So bloody what if it is a 'big secret'...I dont care if its printed as a book and a bestseller...the more this thread gets stupid, the less I care about the whole thing, its doing nothing to sell it to me...and it never will.