Originally posted by moste
View Post
The problem I see is that if Alphon had been the gunman and Valerie had seen enough of his face to produce a reasonable likeness of him after the event, it makes no sense that she would then not recognise him again when he stood there in plain sight at the first id parade.
Valerie's picture may have looked like Alphon to others, but what good was it if it didn't look like Alphon to her?
I thought the usual objection to her not recognising Alphon, but going on to pick out Hanratty at the second id parade, was that she hadn't seen the gunman's face clearly enough to know him again, and had to rely on voice recognition. Not sure you can have it both ways.
Love,
Caz
X
Leave a comment: