The Grisly

[Cogidubnus]

What kind of reality?

I think that "Leather Apron" had some small portion of reality to him and I think of Richardson's words about the REAL "Leather Apron."

Of course, "The Star" and some other papers played this up to sell copy. I think that Mr. Begg wrote a "Rip" article on precisely this.

I know epilepsy, in itself, is a far cry from criminality...my much esteemed former brother in law suffers from it...but Deb's recent disclosures re Richardson are making me wonder...

There are cases of mildly mentally-ill persons in whom the onset of epileptic activity actually cause violence...Back in the early seventies I used to work for a local charity in Brighton, and as part of our activities we used to try to bridge the gap between mental hospitals (as they then existed) and the outside world...I recall X a thoroughly institutionalised elderly gentleman who I'd known for a couple of years...totally personable and ostensibly gentle in every way - we'd taken him and a number of others from a local institution out for a ride around (in a minibus), for a bit of a jolly and a meal every Sunday...

I'd chatted to the gent in question about all sorts of subjects...especially railway history on which he was pretty expert...on this Sunday however, mid-ride, he suddenly suffered an epileptic fit (it was later established he'd skipped his medication) and attempted to strangle our driver (who unfortunately was negotiating the winding and steep downhill road from Ditchling Beacon down to Ditchling in Sussex)...we were fortunate that the driver that day was a particularly burly gentleman, and managed to stop the minibus just before we could drive off the edge of the road (a big drop!)...

My point is, after the incident X had no recollection whatever it had occurred...could Richardson thus be responsible for one of the JtR killings? And if so, who did Polly? Could it be five killers for five victims Lynn?

Dave

[Simon Wood]

Hi Dave,

Think of LA as a prototype JtR.

Second time lucky.

Regards,

Simon

[Cogidubnus]

Yes Simon...but that wasn't quite this early was it?

Dave

[lynn cates]

real "Leather Apron"

Hello Dave. Well sometimes I almost think that any theory is as good as another.

I think that "Leather Apron" had some small portion of reality to him and I think of Richardson's words about the REAL "Leather Apron."

Of course, "The Star" and some other papers played this up to sell copy. I think that Mr. Begg wrote a "Rip" article on precisely this.

Cheers.
LC

[Simon Wood]

Hi Dave,

It wasn't society who had to invent LA/JtR as a reality.

That was done for them, London-wide posters and all.

Regards,

Simon

[lynn cates]

Is there an "Echo" in here?

Hello Simon. Thanks. I was thinking about the various stories, sightings etc. In particular, I am thinking of an "Echo" article from 10 September in which a man answering to the description of "Leather Apron" entered a house in Holloway on Eltham (sic) Road.

Cheers.
LC

[Cogidubnus]

Unless Lynn you were actually arguing that if JtR (or LA) didn't exist as a reality, society would have had to invent him as a reality?

If that were the case, wouldn't the unholy trinity and Richardson, in turn, be as good a fit as JI ?

(heh heh)

Dave

[Simon Wood]

Hi Lynn,

If that means did LA/JtR have no foundation in truth but varied its meaning according to changing circumstances [or political expedience], then YES, that's a big thumbs-up.

Regards,

Simon

[lynn cates]

LA

Hello Simon. Do you think that "Leather Apron" had a fundamentum in re? I am thinking of both the original "Star" piece and "The Times" take on it.

Cheers.
LC

[Simon Wood]

Hi Lynn,

Why not?

It sure beats the non-existent Leather Apron and Jack the Ripper.

Regards,

Simon

[Cogidubnus]

conspiracy of silence

Or an unholy trinity?

Dave

[lynn cates]

3 choices?

Hello Simon. Then it would seem to be Tomkins, Britten or Mumford?

Cheers.
LC

[Simon Wood]

Hi Lynn,

Through the yard from Winthrop Street, quick peek through the gates to see if anyone's about in Bucks Row, dump body, close gates, back out through yard into Winthrop Street, back home in time to act surprised.

Why make it any more difficult?

Regards,

Simon

[lynn cates]

Cui Bono--Sonny's brother.

Hello Simon. Good point, and one must consider all angles. But, hypothetically, is there anything to be gained from having Polly killed there and removed to Buck's Row?

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

Buck's Row, again

Hello Roy. Thanks. In which case Buck's Row seems the place where it happened.

Cheers.
LC