Watkins or Harvey?

[packers stem]

Any chance someone would lay out a short paragraph abstracting the argument here.

I can't follow the argument anymore; you guys are jumping each other's individual sentences and everything now sounds (at least to me) out of context. I need someone to restate the theory you are all debating so I have a bench mark to work of.

Thanks

The post just got sidetracked that's all .
It's supposed to be about the testimony of Watkins against that of Harvey and the way in which they are incompatible