Hi Michael.
Noted, thankyou.
I'm aware of that Michael. We do not have a sufficiently broad window of time which to make a reasonable judgement.
You can hardly insist she could never go out when witnesses saw her out, because then your argument must shift to dismissing any witnesses in order to substantiate your argument.
This is how destructive arguments work, when someone gets an idea in their head they must then set about to destroy any 'historically established' evidence which opposes their idea.
But Michael, I do not need to look for evidence that Kelly was out after 1:00 am, she was seen, the story is part of the historical record.
When all the silly theories have long since fallen by the wayside we will still be reading about what Hutchinson, Lewis & Kennedy saw that night.
Arguing that although Mary Kelly had a room, with a fire, and a bed, at her disposal, yet she chose to solicit out on the streets on a cold and wet night is illogical to say the least.
The obvious needs no justification, however to try claim the opposite needs every justification, no-one has come up with one yet.
Now, if you choose to take the position that Mary was not prostituting herself,.... good luck with that.
Regards, Jon S.
Originally posted by Michael W Richards
View Post
Ive cited the facts about the possibility she brought clients into her room ever, which boil down to only a few nights past November 3rd,.. 2 of which we can account for... we know she wasnt out soliciting those nights.
You can hardly insist she could never go out when witnesses saw her out, because then your argument must shift to dismissing any witnesses in order to substantiate your argument.
This is how destructive arguments work, when someone gets an idea in their head they must then set about to destroy any 'historically established' evidence which opposes their idea.
What you suggest about Mary bringing clients into her room amounts to a belief that she had only begun doing so within 2-3 days of her murder.
When all the silly theories have long since fallen by the wayside we will still be reading about what Hutchinson, Lewis & Kennedy saw that night.
Arguing that although Mary Kelly had a room, with a fire, and a bed, at her disposal, yet she chose to solicit out on the streets on a cold and wet night is illogical to say the least.
The obvious needs no justification, however to try claim the opposite needs every justification, no-one has come up with one yet.
Now, if you choose to take the position that Mary was not prostituting herself,.... good luck with that.
Regards, Jon S.
Comment