NoJak

[Roy Corduroy]

Hypothesis: There was no Serial Killer murdering women in Whitechapel, London in 1888. Whether nicknamed Jack the Ripper or not doesn't matter. Was there a serial murderer?

[Roy Corduroy]

Early results show them running neck and neck but this poll will stay open to infinity and beyond. So jump in!

Remember you vote is anonymous. Just like the real thing.

Roy

[Herlock Sholmes]

Just checking Roy. Do you have to be bald to vote on a Nojak thread?

[Harry D]

Of course not.

Throat slicing & ritual disembowelment is just part and parcel of living in a big city.

[Michael W Richards]

Not only was there one.....there were at least 2 as far as I can see. Maybe more. Jack does 5 of the Unsolved File, Torso man does 2...so who does the remaining victims? Could multiples be by one man? Sure.

[Herlock Sholmes]

14% is higher than I expected.

[Sam Flynn]

14% is higher than I expected.

It's still a pretty small sample size, Herlock. At time of writing, that 14% might represent the only two people here who don't believe there was an SK at work!

[Herlock Sholmes]

It's still a pretty small sample size, Herlock. At time of writing, that 14% might represent the only two people here who don't believe there was an SK at work!

True of course Sam.

Has David Icke voted yet?

[mpriestnall]

I voted Yes for a serial killer. I have my own candidate, doh!

However, I still think the police/politicians knew more about the murders than they admitted and may have distorted the public
conception of them, perhaps using the newspapers to do so.

Martyn

[Jon Guy]

Early results show them running neck and neck but this poll will stay open to infinity and beyond. So jump in!

Remember you vote is anonymous. Just like the real thing.

Roy

I voted YES. But, if the NO`s win can we have a second, People`s Vote ? Just like the real thing.

[Herlock Sholmes]

I voted YES. But, if the NO`s win can we have a second, People`s Vote ? Just like the real thing.

[John G]

I voted YES. But, if the NO`s win can we have a second, People`s Vote ? Just like the real thing.

I'm afraid not, Jon. NoJack means NoJack. It doesn't, for instance, mean "perhaps Jack". Importantly, a second referendum, in these circumstances, would clearly be an absolute betrayal of the expressed will of the Caaebook fraternity. Neither would it be democratic. As a general rule, people are not allowed to change their minds in a democracy. It just isn't cricket. However, if the "Yes" vote is successful then, of course, a second People's vote would be acceptable, probably even desirable, especially as there is clear precedent to allow a second vote in these circumstances, i.e. second referendum on Scottish independence, second referendum on Brexit, following defeats for these proposals in the mid 70's.

I hope this clears up any confusion regarding the matter.

[Jon Guy]

I'm afraid not, Jon. NoJack means NoJack. It doesn't, for instance, mean "perhaps Jack". Importantly, a second referendum, in these circumstances, would clearly be an absolute betrayal of the expressed will of the Caaebook fraternity. Neither would it be democratic. As a general rule, people are not allowed to change their minds in a democracy. It just isn't cricket. However, if the "Yes" vote is successful then, of course, a second People's vote would be acceptable, probably even desirable, especially as there is clear precedent to allow a second vote in these circumstances, i.e. second referendum on Scottish independence, second referendum on Brexit, following defeats for these proposals in the mid 70's.

I hope this clears up any confusion regarding the matter.

Yes, thanks for clarifying matters, John.
But, being a modern man, I will stamp and stamp my feet until I get the result I want.

[Abby Normal]

I voted Yes for a serial killer. I have my own candidate, doh!

However, I still think the police/politicians knew more about the murders than they admitted and may have distorted the public
conception of them, perhaps using the newspapers to do so.

Martyn

hi Martyn
whos your suspect and why do you suspect him?

[Herlock Sholmes]

Yes, thanks for clarifying matters, John.
But, being a modern man, I will stamp and stamp my feet until I get the result I want.

Maybe someone said “that it was best of three” but we weren’t paying attention Jon?