Alexander J Parker

[Addy]

Ooookkkaaaayyyy I think I kniw enough! Thank you Herlock, for your comments! I’ll skip this one, Freemasons and astrology and esoterics are not my cup of tea.

[Herlock Sholmes]

I just realised I read it a which book you are talking about, I read it a couple of months ago. There's a lot of work gone into it, and I guess you have to respect that, but unfortunately it has holes you could drive a giant redwood on the back of a truck through!

That about sums it up for me too Dusty. He goes from looking into an aspect of the case to an undeniable conclusion far too often and far too quickly for me. He then follows up with the an priori position.

We know that these murders were a design so let’s find out what the design was

then its..

We know that these were Freemasonic murders so.....

Then he plucks Treves out of the hat!

[Herlock Sholmes]

Ooookkkaaaayyyy I think I kniw enough! Thank you Herlock, for your comments! I’ll skip this one, Freemasons and astrology and esoterics are not my cup of tea.

As Dusty said, the guys put in a lot of time and effort but that’s about it. Nothing new of value here.