If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Jack the Ripper and Black Magic: Victorian Conspiracy Theories, Secret Societies and
Though he stalks the Whitechapel streets through the night.
His daylight disguise is to hide in plain sight.
Regards, Jon S.
...and maybe even enjoying a fourth showing of Mansfield's Jekyll and Hyde at the Lyceum Theatre! Even if it was mere coincidence, how interesting that this was the show playing.
Hello All. For those who wish more information on PJP Tynan, here is a link to a digitised version of his book, "The Irish National Invincibles and their Times."
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident." - Arthur Schopenhauer
No it's not. Your chapter of much discussion is 'Whitechapel Secret Service', which in an earlier post I suggested would make a good book if expanded, and I also commented that I like the title. I suspect Slemen did too.
No it's not. Your chapter of much discussion is 'Whitechapel Secret Service', which in an earlier post I suggested would make a good book if expanded, and I also commented that I like the title. I suspect Slemen did too.
Tom (Slemen) Wescott,
I appreciate that, though Slemen is tolerated as a crank and a mate of Chris George's, you may want to promote his wares. But there is already a thread for that.
It is pointless discussing anything with you when you rely on shoddy references.
Jack the Ripper Writers -- An online community of crime writers and historians.
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident." - Arthur Schopenhauer
This will be my last post on this thread, and I will now not be writing my planned review of your book. I will remain silent on the matter. I have been very clear in everything I've said, and I pointed out that I only posted what I did about Slemen because the new title of his book is very similar to your Chapter 7 title. You're clearly not familiar with what I had to say about Slemen's book when it was first published in print, or you would not accuse me of using your thread to promote his work. I was not aware that he's a friend of Chris George, nor do I see how that is significant. I do not appreciate being called Tom (Slemen) Wescott. You are extraordinarily paranoid, Spiro, and this has caused you to alienate a great many people and I don't even want to guess at the impact your behavior has had and will have on your book sales, but I'm certain it's significant.
Nobody will be posting on this thread now, Spiro, or at least not nice things. It will die and go away.
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident." - Arthur Schopenhauer
Hello All. For those who wish more information on PJP Tynan, here is a link to a digitised version of his book, "The Irish National Invincibles and their Times."
Thanks for this link Lynn, of course this is the modified English edition after the US version had emerged.
There are considerable primary sources on Tynan located at the UK National Archives if anyone cares to check, but caution is advised as Tynan was also suspected, as was McDermott, of dual loyalties.
If anyone is wondering why this is at all relevant to Jack the Ripper and the Whitechapel murders it is because of documented Scotland Yard active investigation in this direction, despite the beliefs or agendas of some.
The active investigation on the East End mutilation murders of 1888, contrary to fantasy inspired by modern forensics, were not internally considered as sexual serial killings. They were regarded as terrorist acts during a distinctly Victorian political episode.
We now have sources and evidence that indicates this was the reality of the Whitechapel murders and why the killer managed to escape, elude police and locals silently and swiftly committing the crimes.
These further documentary sources were under the administrative control of Anderson, Littlechild, Macnaghten, Swanson, the Home Secretary and Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, James Monro.
Lynn,
I have a copy of an addendum inserted into the US edition of Tynan's book that makes for interesting reading and I'll transcribe it here:
ADDENDUM
As the English edition is passing through the press, the following additions are being made to the American text:-
"The proclamation of the I.R.B. (see p. 272), we have since learned, was not issued by the official executive of the I.R.B., but by some of the officers who were in sympathy with the INVINCIBLE action in Dublin."
"Since this (see p. 440) was written one of these gentlemen has had the courage of his convictions. In the city of Troy, New York, during the American political campaign of 1888, an Irishman and a graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, addressing a political meeting, openly avowed his sympathy with the Irish INVINCIBLE movement. He there publicly declared that not only had he been a member of that organisation, but that he was the purchaser of the irregular weapons of warfare used by the INVINCIBLES in the Phoenix Park, Dublin. Owing to the prevarication and timidity, if not moral cowardice, on the part of the leaders of the movement, this public announcement of his created a profound impression on his hearers."
Jack the Ripper Writers -- An online community of crime writers and historians.
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident." - Arthur Schopenhauer
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident." - Arthur Schopenhauer
In the city of Troy, New York, during the American political campaign of 1888, an Irishman and a graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, addressing a political meeting, openly avowed his sympathy with the Irish INVINCIBLE movement. He there publicly declared that not only had he been a member of that organisation, but that he was the purchaser of the irregular weapons of warfare used by the INVINCIBLES in the Phoenix Park, Dublin.
Certainly Wolf, that's how the story goes. Perhaps you can also explain this addendum entry in the American edition of Tynan's, The Irish National Invincibles and their Times.
Thanks
Spiro
Jack the Ripper Writers -- An online community of crime writers and historians.
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident." - Arthur Schopenhauer
Originally posted by auspirograph: In the city of Troy, New York, during the American political campaign of 1888, an Irishman and a graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, addressing a political meeting, openly avowed his sympathy with the Irish INVINCIBLE movement. He there publicly declared that not only had he been a member of that organisation, but that he was the purchaser of the irregular weapons of warfare used by the INVINCIBLES in the Phoenix Park, Dublin.
Certainly Wolf, that's how the story goes. Perhaps you can also explain this addendum entry in the American edition of Tynan's, The Irish National Invincibles and their Times.
I’m not sure exactly what you want explained to you. Dr. Hamilton Williams was an Irishman living in and around New York, a member of the Invincibles, the man who reportedly purchased the knives used in the Phoenix Park murders and was also a graduate of Trinity College. Presumably, therefore, Tynan was writing about Williams.
The active investigation on the East End mutilation murders of 1888, contrary to fantasy inspired by modern forensics, were not internally considered as sexual serial killings. They were regarded as terrorist acts during a distinctly Victorian political episode.
Good Morning,
Interesting thread, and I would appreciate your thoughts on some matters -- if you have the time.
Would you please tell me from what point the killings were regarded as terrorist acts?
From the very beginning with Tabram?
Maybe during the period following Chapman when the people were so aroused?
After Mary Kelly?
Or was the view that the murders were terrorist acts the reason for Anderson's appointment? Since he was appointed in August before the series really started . . . Was he appointed because the government was virtually certain "a plot was afoot?" and they would be dealing with a major terrorist outbreak of some sort?
Comment