Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Unsolved Mysteries

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Linotte
    replied
    Originally posted by Geddy2112 View Post
    Yes I posted about it in another thread. It's rather 'entry level' which I believe from Facebook comments that is where it was aimed. Only mistake I spotted was they forgot the 'u' when spelling Neighbour. Apart from that very enjoyable. Was great to see four of the top big hitters not mentioning at all a certain Mr Lechmere, that made some folk Cross

    Yeah, errors with regard to locations during re-enactments have always been kind of a thing with “Unsolved Mysteries.” I don’t know if you’ve listened to the podcast “The Trail Went Cold,” which recaps old Unsolved Mysteries cases, but the host, Robin Warner, makes sure to mention it when it happens.

    I enjoyed it. It was really well done and I didn’t feel like I was being gaslit or condescended to, which tends to happen with documentaries like these when someone has an agenda to push. It presented the case to a newer audience in a clear, concise manner. I think the scriptwriters did a good job of connecting the issues with poverty and lack of social safety net to why the victims had to resort to prostitution. It was emphasized a few times that the women were just trying to survive and that the killer is solely to blame for what happened. I think the call for more info, artifacts, and even scholarship will yield a lot of interesting finds in the near future.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geddy2112
    replied
    Originally posted by The Rookie Detective View Post


    I particularly liked the not too subtle "please give back any authentic Ripper artifacts that you may have taken" (paraphrasing) at the very end of the documentary.
    No sir, I'm keeping the two knives I have with blood and finger prints on them, won them fair and square in a game of Texas Hold em...

    Leave a comment:


  • The Rookie Detective
    replied
    Originally posted by Barnaby View Post
    There is a new Netflix Jack the Ripper documentary on the new Unsolved Mysteries (Season 4, Episode 1). Paul Begg, Richard Jones, Lindsay Siviter, and Adam Wood are featured. I found the documentary factual, however the reenactments could have been improved. They seemingly used the same set for all of the murders, most glaringly Annie Chapman being found on cobblestones.

    Anyone else watch this?


    Watched it last night.

    It was a generic standard documentary that worked at a basic level to introduce newcomers to the case.

    Outside of which it offered nothing new in terms of insight.

    I found it comical that Lechmere wasn't mentioned and bizarre that Chapman was laying on cobbles.

    It lacked any significant reconstructive realism, but was well presented nonetheless.

    I would love to see a more realistic gritty documentary that focuses on realism in terms of what we know, ergo, what each victim was wearing and body positions etc...

    Overall it was well worth a watch, but packed any real substance in terms of potential case progression.

    I particularly liked the not too subtle "please give back any authentic Ripper artifacts that you may have taken" (paraphrasing) at the very end of the documentary.

    There are almost certainly pieces of potentially key physical evidence that are still out there somewhere, and so it was a nice touch to highlight the plight so to speak.


    RD
    Last edited by The Rookie Detective; 08-06-2024, 01:37 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • The Rookie Detective
    replied
    Originally posted by Fiver View Post

    The best that I have seen is a Youtube video by Lemmino.
    Ah yes! I have watched that. It was excellent and rather refreshing in comparison to a lot of other Ripper documentaries

    I had forgotten about that; thankyou for reminding me of that excellent documentary


    RD

    Leave a comment:


  • Fiver
    replied
    Originally posted by The Rookie Detective View Post

    Haven't seen it yet, but planning to asap.


    I find it astonishing how after all these years that there's never been a definitively accurate (as possible) documentary that provides facts and analysis without committing the cardinal sin of trying to tell us who the Ripper was rather than allow us to make up our own minds


    RD
    The best that I have seen is a Youtube video by Lemmino.

    Leave a comment:


  • The Rookie Detective
    replied
    Originally posted by Barnaby View Post
    There is a new Netflix Jack the Ripper documentary on the new Unsolved Mysteries (Season 4, Episode 1). Paul Begg, Richard Jones, Lindsay Siviter, and Adam Wood are featured. I found the documentary factual, however the reenactments could have been improved. They seemingly used the same set for all of the murders, most glaringly Annie Chapman being found on cobblestones.

    Anyone else watch this?


    Haven't seen it yet, but planning to asap.


    I find it astonishing how after all these years that there's never been a definitively accurate (as possible) documentary that provides facts and analysis without committing the cardinal sin of trying to tell us who the Ripper was rather than allow us to make up our own minds


    RD

    Leave a comment:


  • Simon Wood
    replied
    It was terrible, a warmed-over hotchpotch of cliches and old tropes which added not a jot to our understanding. The presenters should have known better.​

    Leave a comment:


  • Geddy2112
    replied
    Yes I posted about it in another thread. It's rather 'entry level' which I believe from Facebook comments that is where it was aimed. Only mistake I spotted was they forgot the 'u' when spelling Neighbour. Apart from that very enjoyable. Was great to see four of the top big hitters not mentioning at all a certain Mr Lechmere, that made some folk Cross

    Leave a comment:


  • Herlock Sholmes
    replied
    Cheers Barnaby, I’ll have a look.

    Leave a comment:


  • Duran duren
    replied
    I have not but thanks for letting us know.

    Leave a comment:


  • Barnaby
    started a topic Unsolved Mysteries

    Unsolved Mysteries

    There is a new Netflix Jack the Ripper documentary on the new Unsolved Mysteries (Season 4, Episode 1). Paul Begg, Richard Jones, Lindsay Siviter, and Adam Wood are featured. I found the documentary factual, however the reenactments could have been improved. They seemingly used the same set for all of the murders, most glaringly Annie Chapman being found on cobblestones.

    Anyone else watch this?



Working...
X