The Identity of Israel Schwartz

[DVV]

I think the data that we all know suggests that the Police didnt believe his story

Hi Mike,
and what about Swanson (19 October - of course!):

"I Schwartz is to be believed, and the police report of his statement casts no doubt upon it..."

Amitiés mon cher,
David

[Sam Flynn]

Nor do we know why Goldstein doesnt show up until Tuesday night to explain himself. If they believe he lied....did they believe that was due to an allegiance of some kind to the Socialist Jews at The International Club? His story was the only one that suggested directly that a Club man was likely not involved.

I've started a thread called "The Berner Street (Con)spiracy", for those who aren't particularly interested in the "Identity of Israel Schwartz"

[perrymason]

I saw that and went there Sam....just giving you some fuel for a reason for him to change his name to John.

David,...no less mesmerized than Abberline was of Hutchinson? We know why Hutch wasnt called, they didnt know he existed pre-Inquest.

But Schwartz they did know before. And not one iota of his story is offered or entered into evidence...let alone an appearance on the stand.

He has the single most significant witness sighting in all of the series....he sees a Canonical tussle with a man minutes from her murder and only feet from it. No other witness sees overt aggression just prior. And he is left off the record. We dont even have his official translated statement...we have recollections of it.

Best regards

[Sam Flynn]

He has the single most significant witness sighting in all of the series....he sees a Canonical tussle with a man minutes from her murder and only feet from it. No other witness sees overt aggression just prior. And he is left off the record.

Indeed - and that's "conspiracy talk" where I come from, Mike. Thanks for spotting - and using - the thread I set up on that very topic