Vote Here

[Sam Flynn]

A gang of men for me.


...that's what I voted, not a request

[Mitch Rowe]

This case is such an enigmatic one that there are good arguments for and against all four options.

No doubt. No wonder why Abberline turned to drugs!

[Mitch Rowe]

I had to vote a simple gang of men. I have no real evidence to assume Emma was lying. Of course A gang of men that included JTR would be my next choice.

[sdreid]

This case is such an enigmatic one that there are good arguments for and against all four options.

[Celesta]

I'm sitting on the fence, Roy. (I don't recommend that!) I went for numero four, because I think we could be dealing with proto-Jack.

[Jon Guy]

I have gone for Jack the Ripper, based on the nature of the injury targetting the abdomen and private parts.

[sdreid]

If I was going to rank the choices in order of likelihood, I'd say 4, 3 (probably someone she knew), 1 and 2.

[sdreid]

Thanks Roy,

I went with option 4. That doesn't mean that it's an over 50% chance with me, just that it rates higher than the other 3 choices in my view. All four choices are pretty good ones.

[Roy Corduroy]

Please vote your opinion as to the true facts of the murder of Emma Smith.