Hi Sam, Chava,
Im sorry for handling this with sarcasm Gareth, because I do know that you are intent on this answer to the question, Ive mostly been testy because youre not even acknowledging the precarious perch the statement has, when viewed in the entire collection of articles on that night and that court. As I said, I defended your right to the opinion before, and even modified my own beliefs out of respect, that being that I do not believe a voice could be heard as described by Elizabeth via a front window so I suggested a front and rear, that might be in some way confirmed by the post of Chris's referring to her room over the "gateway". If her room bordered the archway, which it almost certainly did, then that window in the archway over the court could be as I said, in the rear corner or her room..if there is a slight alcove there. And she would ostensibly be "over the shed".
Its that you are moving ahead before I or anyone who shares my opinion has been acknowledged as a having valid evidence in hand that does suggest a different scenario.
Thanks for following up on the time on the light in the room Chava, I found that interesting too....and in that account a trip out seems unlikely....it paints the two as sharing the evening together, her and Blotchy.
Told ya....he is not out of the woods on this at all.
edit....I just had a thought,....what if Blotchys job was to get Mary to drink something to knock her out, then leave her to "Mr X".
Cheers gents, all.
Im sorry for handling this with sarcasm Gareth, because I do know that you are intent on this answer to the question, Ive mostly been testy because youre not even acknowledging the precarious perch the statement has, when viewed in the entire collection of articles on that night and that court. As I said, I defended your right to the opinion before, and even modified my own beliefs out of respect, that being that I do not believe a voice could be heard as described by Elizabeth via a front window so I suggested a front and rear, that might be in some way confirmed by the post of Chris's referring to her room over the "gateway". If her room bordered the archway, which it almost certainly did, then that window in the archway over the court could be as I said, in the rear corner or her room..if there is a slight alcove there. And she would ostensibly be "over the shed".
Its that you are moving ahead before I or anyone who shares my opinion has been acknowledged as a having valid evidence in hand that does suggest a different scenario.
Thanks for following up on the time on the light in the room Chava, I found that interesting too....and in that account a trip out seems unlikely....it paints the two as sharing the evening together, her and Blotchy.
Told ya....he is not out of the woods on this at all.
edit....I just had a thought,....what if Blotchys job was to get Mary to drink something to knock her out, then leave her to "Mr X".
Cheers gents, all.
Comment