Walter Sickert: Whitechapel Murderer ?

[babybird67]

another never...

for me Barry.

[Rosey O'Ryan]

What, is it the weekend already? My answer...zero, zip, zilch, not a chance. Sickert was across the Channel doing art at nearly all of the relevant times.

Dear Maurice,

Exactly. Nemo was too busy perfecting his art at the time. Golly gosh, witness his masterpiece, 'October Sun', which, in my own opinion, is an extraordinary glimpse into the viscera of a butcher's shop.
What more can one say.
Rosey :-)

[Mascara & Paranoia]

Never.

What evidence is there that he (or any of the other suspects for that matter) were even in Whitechapel the night of any one of the murders? What evidence is there linking him or any of the suspects to any of the victims in a way that strongly indicates that they killed them? Precisely none. It's all just speculation and theories and the majority of it is weak at best.

If anything, Sickert was probably just a Jacky fanboy of his time. Nothing more.

[Mitch Rowe]

I voted 2 because I never say never when it comes to suspect unless they can be absolutely positively eliminated.

[sdreid]

I'd say about a 1.5 but I'll round it up to a 2.

[Khanada]

What, is it the weekend already? My answer...zero, zip, zilch, not a chance. Sickert was across the Channel doing art at nearly all of the relevant times.

I would agree, other than to ask if there is a number lower than zero that I can use in my reply...

[The Grave Maurice]

What, is it the weekend already? My answer...zero, zip, zilch, not a chance. Sickert was across the Channel doing art at nearly all of the relevant times.

[halomanuk]

Ok all,
Another in the series to see the grades from 1-10 .
After seeing a slight eruption on the 'Cornwell' thread it is time to bring Walter Sickert into the ring.

We are all aware of the Sickert/J.K Stephen combo ,so if you base your score on that then please mention it .

The usual : 1= NEVER,10= DEFINATE.