The Diary — Old Hoax or New or Not a Hoax at All?​

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Lombro2
    Sergeant
    • Jun 2023
    • 625

    #1726
    Go back to arguing with the people who agree with you on your conclusion. Maybe they’re wrong like you but for the right reasons. Or maybe they’re right about how the fake diary wasn’t faked, and for the right reasons, unlike you and yours, which is something you appear not to abide.
    Last edited by Lombro2; Today, 12:11 AM.
    A Northern Italian invented Criminology but Thomas Harris surpassed us all. Except for Michael Barrett and his Diary of Jack the Ripper.

    Comment

    • Herlock Sholmes
      Commissioner
      • May 2017
      • 22584

      #1727
      Originally posted by Lombro2 View Post
      Go back to arguing with the people who agree with you on your conclusion. Maybe they’re wrong like you but for the right reasons. Or maybe they’re right about how the fake diary wasn’t faked for the right reasons, unlike you and yours, which is something you appear not to abide.

      So I ran your post through an online English to Italian translator and then back from Italian to English to see if it would help me understand it better and it came up with this:

      "Go back and discuss with the people who agree with your conclusion. Maybe they're wrong, like you, but for the right reasons. Or maybe they're right that the fake diary wasn't fabricated for the right reasons, unlike you and your family, which you apparently don't accept."

      I'd say it probably makes more sense in this form.
      Herlock Sholmes

      ”I don’t know who Jack the Ripper was…and neither do you.”

      Comment

      • Herlock Sholmes
        Commissioner
        • May 2017
        • 22584

        #1728
        Originally posted by Lombro2 View Post
        Based on an argument I think is bonkers and I’m being kind.

        But I’m in the minority according to you so it doesn’t matter. Of course, I’m actually in the majority of the people who actually understand the argument.
        Based on an argument which you have proven time and time again that you don’t understand Lombro. If you did understand it you wouldn’t keep mentioning ‘one off’ as a stand-alone phrase. But you keep doing it.

        You and the defenders have now had 10 years to come up with one example from somewhere, just one, that refutes the point. But none of you have. And do you know why Lombro? Because that point of rebuttal doesn’t exist. 10 whole years and counting…..

        All that you have is “surely this can’t be the case.” That’s it. David Barrat provided full evidenced proper research. Tracked through the years and following the way that language works in reality. You on the other hand rely on desperate wish-thinking. It’s sad to see that you and others are so committed to this fake that you will do and say absolutely anything to try and prop it up….as today’s lamentable, easily disproven charade has proven.
        Herlock Sholmes

        ”I don’t know who Jack the Ripper was…and neither do you.”

        Comment

        • Lombro2
          Sergeant
          • Jun 2023
          • 625

          #1729
          Sorry but you’re asking me to cherry pick for cherries that are in someone else’s backyard or kitchen. You can’t find something where you can’t go.

          If your forger picked a Londoner, I might believe you. As it stands, I wouldn’t put it past a Liverpudlian to say, “I’m giving birth to the 20th Century!”
          A Northern Italian invented Criminology but Thomas Harris surpassed us all. Except for Michael Barrett and his Diary of Jack the Ripper.

          Comment

          • Lombro2
            Sergeant
            • Jun 2023
            • 625

            #1730
            You both exemplify English As A First Language. You just can’t analyze it because you grew up with it. I might as well ask Wayne Gretzky to explain hockey or coach my team.

            RJ would probably want to hire Micky Mantle. I’d try a back catcher. I know. Not so glamorous. Not so “elitist”.

            Im an amateurish all the way. Amateurs are usually the best at individual skill. Solving rubiks too.
            A Northern Italian invented Criminology but Thomas Harris surpassed us all. Except for Michael Barrett and his Diary of Jack the Ripper.

            Comment

            Working...
            X