After almost 30 years of debate, where do you stand on the Maybrick Diary?

[Observer]

I'm partial to a bit sarcasm myself. I think it suits you.

Thanks for the compliment, much appreciated.

[Observer]

Not a bad attempt at comedy Yabs, quite good. In comparison to the usual fodder on display, it's pure genius

[Iconoclast]

Actually, I thought it was very clever, Yabs, and it certainly made me chuckle quite violently before subsiding back to safe levels of smiling profusely.

Observer appears to have intolerably high bars set for his cracking-up point ...

[Christian]

I think I would add another category -- Are you absolutely amazed by the amount of time people spend debating the damn diary?

Put me down as a very big yes.

c.d.

Indeed!! Find it after all these decades a little boring

[Ms Diddles]

Not a bad attempt at comedy Yabs, quite good. In comparison to the usual fodder on display, it's pure genius

Yep! Made me laugh too!

[Scott Nelson]

I didn't vote because I can't shoehorn my theory into any of the selections. Two Diaries -- one old, the other recent.

[barnflatwyngarde]

I didn't vote because I can't shoehorn my theory into any of the selections. Two Diaries -- one old, the other recent.

Oh, don't encourage them Scott.

[Varqm]

The field should be renamed Barretology or Grahamology.
Happy New Year everybody.

[Iconoclast]

The field should be renamed Barretology or Grahamology.
Happy New Year everybody.

A good point, well made sir!

I simply must overcome Commercialmas before venturing to wish Hogmanay happiness to all and sundry, but many thanks for inadvertently reminding me to get Mrs Iconoclast an anniversary gift for the 31st ...

Ike

[rjpalmer]

No worries, Ike. I figure the 23 people worldwide who mistakenly believe Mudbrick was the Ripper will eventually find this poll, at which time you can withdraw your snarky comment about mob rule, and Caz can similarly withdraw her suggestion that the non-believers must all be akin to the supporters of a political movement she despises. Time Will Heal All.

[Varqm]

A good point, well made sir!

I simply must overcome Commercialmas before venturing to wish Hogmanay happiness to all and sundry, but many thanks for inadvertently reminding me to get Mrs Iconoclast an anniversary gift for the 31st ...

Ike

She will be happy, the odds are for.

[Abby Normal]

after reading Lord orsams latest, I realized I never voted in this poll. Obviously the barrets hoaxed it-its as clear as the nose on your face.

[Abby Normal]

Not a bad attempt at comedy Yabs, quite good. In comparison to the usual fodder on display, it's pure genius

Yup that one good.
this one by harry even better

diarya.Thats my vote

[Fanatic]

I believe the answers to these polls are anonymous, so I am hoping we get people to give their honest viewpoint.

I have not set an end-date.

Maybrick still has to be top of the suspect list… You certainly couldn’t claim it was anyone else with any sincerity until you had looked at him in detail

[DJA]

Only if you are very gullible.