Charles Allen Lechmere - new suspect?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • DirectorDave
    *
    • Sep 2009
    • 355

    #706
    Hi DirectorDave

    Yeah the doc is a load of bilge.

    Cheers John
    I think you're having your jollies with me.

    I thought it was one of the better suspect ones, I was especially impressed with the mapping.

    If I ever was to communicate with any of those involved I'd say "well done".

    Comment

    • Pierre
      Inactive
      • Sep 2015
      • 4407

      #707
      Originally posted by John Wheat View Post
      Hi Pierre

      Yes he's both a boring and terrible suspect I don't know why he's discussed so often on these boards.

      Cheers John
      Probably just because of that.

      Regards, Pierre

      Comment

      • John Wheat
        Assistant Commissioner
        • Jul 2008
        • 3347

        #708
        Originally posted by DirectorDave View Post
        I think you're having your jollies with me.

        I thought it was one of the better suspect ones, I was especially impressed with the mapping.

        If I ever was to communicate with any of those involved I'd say "well done".
        Hi DirectorDave

        No I'm really not. It's so biased it's unbelievable.

        Cheers John

        Comment

        • John Wheat
          Assistant Commissioner
          • Jul 2008
          • 3347

          #709
          Originally posted by Pierre View Post
          Probably just because of that.

          Regards, Pierre
          Hi Pierre

          Well actually it's because of Buffoons who have picked Lechmere as there pet suspect. And others who believe there bullshit.

          Cheers John

          Comment

          • Elamarna
            Commissioner
            • Sep 2014
            • 5807

            #710
            Originally posted by Pierre View Post
            It is a shame though that Lechmere is such a boring "suspect".

            Regards, Pierre
            Yes Pierre, boring is the correct word, probably one of the most of all the "suspects".

            Of course that would be ok if he was also the probably killer, which at present i do no see.

            As purely interesting persons, and not as a killer, it is hard to beat Tumblety,

            Steve

            Comment

            • DirectorDave
              *
              • Sep 2009
              • 355

              #711
              Well John, like the old Western question of "Why don't they just shoot the horses?" it would be a tad boring if it's premise was "Here's this new suspect and here's why we don't think he was the ripper."

              Comment

              • John Wheat
                Assistant Commissioner
                • Jul 2008
                • 3347

                #712
                Originally posted by DirectorDave View Post
                Well John, like the old Western question of "Why don't they just shoot the horses?" it would be a tad boring if it's premise was "Here's this new suspect and here's why we don't think he was the ripper."
                Hi DirectorDave

                Yes but the case for Lechmere as JTR is incredibly weak.

                Cheers John

                Comment

                • DirectorDave
                  *
                  • Sep 2009
                  • 355

                  #713
                  Yes but the case for Lechmere as JTR is incredibly weak.
                  I've yet to hear a case against any suspect that was not either "incredibly weak" or "laughable".

                  p.s. Maybe Lewis Carroll...he's more hilarious than laughable.

                  Comment

                  • John Wheat
                    Assistant Commissioner
                    • Jul 2008
                    • 3347

                    #714
                    Originally posted by DirectorDave View Post
                    I've yet to hear a case against any suspect that was not either "incredibly weak" or "laughable".

                    p.s. Maybe Lewis Carroll...he's more hilarious than laughable.
                    Hi DirectorDave

                    Have you ever heard of WH Bury? The main argument against him is that he didn't mutilate his ex prostitute wife's abdomen enough to be JTR. Which is ludicrous when you consider the complete lack of Ripper suspects with any history of knife violence related murders. The only other suspect who is recorded to have used a knife in a murder is James Kelly.

                    Cheers John

                    Comment

                    • DirectorDave
                      *
                      • Sep 2009
                      • 355

                      #715
                      Yes of course I've heard of Bury, I agree he's one of the better named suspects and is thus in the "incredibly weak" column.

                      Comment

                      • John Wheat
                        Assistant Commissioner
                        • Jul 2008
                        • 3347

                        #716
                        Originally posted by DirectorDave View Post
                        Yes of course I've heard of Bury, I agree he's one of the better named suspects and is thus in the "incredibly weak" column.
                        Hi DirectorDave

                        I regard Bury is the strongest suspect by some distance. Although that won't be news to some posters.

                        Cheers John

                        Comment

                        • Elamarna
                          Commissioner
                          • Sep 2014
                          • 5807

                          #717
                          Originally posted by John Wheat View Post
                          Hi DirectorDave

                          Have you ever heard of WH Bury? The main argument against him is that he didn't mutilate his ex prostitute wife's abdomen enough to be JTR. Which is ludicrous when you consider the complete lack of Ripper suspects with any history of knife violence related murders. The only other suspect who is recorded to have used a knife in a murder is James Kelly.

                          Cheers John
                          John

                          The limiting factor in that argument is that it says the killer needs to have been proven to have killed others with a knife.


                          One may be able to use it to a degree, to possible exclude murders who did not use knives, however that does not allow for the possible of the killer changing method, unlikely i know, but possible.

                          And of course if f the killer was never detected, or known for other crimes it just does not work at all John.

                          I will give you that Bury is certainly better than Carrol,

                          sorry


                          Steve

                          Comment

                          • DirectorDave
                            *
                            • Sep 2009
                            • 355

                            #718
                            On a good day he might be top of my list too...but if I was in the jury it would be "Not Guilty".

                            Comment

                            • John Wheat
                              Assistant Commissioner
                              • Jul 2008
                              • 3347

                              #719
                              Originally posted by Elamarna View Post
                              John

                              The limiting factor in that argument is that it says the killer needs to have been proven to have killed others with a knife.


                              One may be able to use it to a degree, to possible exclude murders who did not use knives, however that does not allow for the possible of the killer changing method, unlikely i know, but possible.

                              And of course if f the killer was never detected, or known for other crimes it just does not work at all John.

                              I will give you that Bury is certainly better than Carrol,

                              sorry


                              Steve
                              Hi Steve

                              Bury is a proven violent knife murderer.

                              Bury murdered his ex prostitute wife using pretty much the same M.O. to the C5.

                              Bury matches all the psych profiles incredibly well.

                              Bury was a known user of prostitutes.

                              Bury is known to have been missing from home for days on end.

                              But you probably know all that anyway. Thought I'd type it anyway frankly I'm getting sick of reading all the bullshit about Lechmere and other joke suspects.

                              Cheers John

                              Comment

                              • Elamarna
                                Commissioner
                                • Sep 2014
                                • 5807

                                #720
                                John

                                To be honest Bury is far better than most, he is in the top quarter of my possibles,


                                Still no one in the probables.

                                steve

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X