The BIG Poll

[FISHY1118]

Richard has the same evidence that I have available. There is absolutely no other way of estimating when Thompson went into hospital and how long he stayed there. So if I read Walsh as saying that he went into hospital around mid-October, and Richard also reads in Walsh that he went into hospital in around mid-October how can there be two ‘versions’ from myself and Richard. Try thinking about it Fishy because it’s very, very simple. Richard is just making things up to suit his theory and he did it in the hope that people like you won’t check the evidence.

You support Thompson purely because of me. This is just a fact Fishy. Thompson is a pathetic suspect.

Where does Richard say ''Thompson stayed for six weeks like Walsh did ? your manipulation the words again and left that out as to make a point , a typical Herlockism . Nice try . No Herlock i support Thompson because the evidence against him in my opinion supports it . You woundnt be playing the victim now by any chance would you ?.

[FISHY1118]

Yes they were Fishy!!

Proved with sources quoted. You clearly don’t know what evidence is.

No they werent Herlock.I know the difference between evidence and opinion , you dont .

[Herlock Sholmes]

Where does Richard say ''Thompson stayed for six weeks like Walsh did ? your manipulation the words again and left that out as to make a point , a typical Herlockism . Nice try . No Herlock i support Thompson because the evidence against him in my opinion supports it . You woundnt be playing the victim now by any chance would you ?.

You haven’t read the evidence Fishy. Like Richard though you won’t discuss the specifics of the evidence. Actually I can see why you favour Richard. Like you he won’t answer questions or discuss specifics.

[Herlock Sholmes]

No they werent Herlock.I know the difference between evidence and opinion , you dont .

You support Gull. Enough said.

[FISHY1118]

You support Gull. Enough said.

A more like suspect than Cutbush or Druitt

[FISHY1118]

You haven’t read the evidence Fishy. Like Richard though you won’t discuss the specifics of the evidence. Actually I can see why you favour Richard. Like you he won’t answer questions or discuss specifics.

Tell me Herlock Where does Richard say ''Thompson stayed for six weeks like Walsh did ? , you can admit you stuffed up its ok .

[FISHY1118]

Its getting so boring putting up with such nonsense.

[Doctored Whatsit]

Did you even read my post ?

Yes I did.

[Herlock Sholmes]

A more like suspect than Cutbush or Druitt

And that’s why you get so many people suggesting Gull as a suspect Fishy.

[Herlock Sholmes]

Tell me Herlock Where does Richard say ''Thompson stayed for six weeks like Walsh did ? , you can admit you stuffed up it’s ok .

Post #432 of The Mystery Finally Solved for a start Fishy:

”However, we know Thompson also spent ~6 weeks in a private hospital.”

Ok, it’s betting time again folks. What will Fishy do next?

a) Admit that he was wrong.
b) Try to claim that he was asking something else.
c) Try to change the subject.
d) Just not respond.

I favour c) or d) as they are the usuals.

[Herlock Sholmes]

In post #11 of the Reality Check thread:

”Thompson was admitted into private care for six weeks..”

[Herlock Sholmes]

In post #496 of the Rating the Suspects thread:

“..private hospital for six weeks at the end of 1888..”

[Herlock Sholmes]

In post #3 of the Isreal Schwartz/Pipeman thread:

“..when exhaustion forced him into hospital for six weeks.”

[ohrocky]

Great idea for a poll. Thank you Herlock.

Whilst I'm far from convinced that any of the named suspects committed the murders, I'll have my sixpenneth, just for jollies!

1) Kelly
2) Bury
3) Chapman
4) Anderson's suspect
5) Barnett
6) Druitt

[Herlock Sholmes]

Great idea for a poll. Thank you Herlock.

Whilst I'm far from convinced that any of the named suspects committed the murders, I'll have my sixpenneth, just for jollies!

1) Kelly
2) Bury
3) Chapman
4) Anderson's suspect
5) Barnett
6) Druitt

Cheers Rocky

I knocked up a small list of suspects who I had expected to get a mention but hadn’t as yet. One was Hyams until Pat selected him. The other was Joe Barnett.