The BIG Poll

[Herlock Sholmes]

No Michael! Henry Cox´s suspect, City Police.

https://wiki.casebook.org/henry_cox.html

Karsten.

Sorry Karsten. I’d forgotten about Henry Cox. I’ll make the change.

[FISHY1118]

The obvious problem is that there’s always an agenda with your posts Fishy. I don’t know why you can simply discus the case without getting wrapped up in the people posting. You have always proposed Gull so there is no issue there but you have never expressed any interest in Thompson. All that you’ve said recently is pretty much “Herlock has his opinion and Richard has his, etc.” But just because of the fact that I’ve posted against this you suddenly find Thompson the second strongest suspect.

I’ve added your votes.

Cheers Fishy

No agenda Herlock I've always been happy to debate a topic or suspect ,yes I've proposed Gull and yes I'm of the belief he was the ripper, but like everyone here i could be wrong. If I am then Thompson as I see him, and how Richard has shown his credibility as a excellent suspect is the next best choice in my opinion,I don't see the issue with that line of thought .

Thanks for adding my vote.

[Herlock Sholmes]

No agenda Herlock I've always been happy to debate a topic or suspect ,yes I've proposed Gull and yes I'm of the belief he was the ripper, but like everyone here i could be wrong. If I am then Thompson as I see him, and how Richard has shown his credibility as a excellent suspect is the next best choice in my opinion,I don't see the issue with that line of thought .

Thanks for adding my vote.

So basically you’re judging Thompson on me or Richard rather than looking at the evidence? If you had read the evidence it’s impossible for you to support Richard’s position.

[Sunny Delight]

Do we have to name a suspect or can we include like AK man or BS man?

[Herlock Sholmes]

Do we have to name a suspect or can we include like AK man or BS man?

A nickname is fine SD. People have already named BS man, Blotchy man, Pipeman etc.

[Sunny Delight]

A nickname is fine SD. People have already named BS man, Blotchy man, Pipeman etc.

Thank Herlock. I would thus go with:

1) BS man. I think he was the killer, have him way out ahead of everyone, wouldn't put my house on it mind you.

2) Lawendes man- fairly certain this is BS man goinh by description so could be a joint 1st really.

3) AK man.

4) Kosminski, not necessarily Aaron

5) George Chapman

6) Blotchy Man

7) Bethnal Green botherer described by Sarah Lewis

[Herlock Sholmes]

Thank Herlock. I would thus go with:

1) BS man. I think he was the killer, have him way out ahead of everyone, wouldn't put my house on it mind you.

2) Lawendes man- fairly certain this is BS man goinh by description so could be a joint 1st really.

3) AK man.

4) Kosminski, not necessarily Aaron

5) George Chapman

6) Blotchy Man

7) Bethnal Green botherer described by Sarah Lewis

Just to clarify SD, is AK man…Astrakhan man (Hutchinson’s man)?

[Sunny Delight]

Just to clarify SD, is AK man…Astrakhan man (Hutchinson’s man)?

Yeah AK man or Astrakhan man, the man seen with Mary Kelly by George Hutchinson on the night she was murdered.

[Geddy2112]

Can we vote for 'unknown local man'?

[Herlock Sholmes]

Can we vote for 'unknown local man'?

If you want too.

[Herlock Sholmes]

Yeah AK man or Astrakhan man, the man seen with Mary Kelly by George Hutchinson on the night she was murdered.

Cheers SD

[Geddy2112]

If you want too.

I'll vote for 'Unknown Local Man' then. Cheers

[Herlock Sholmes]

“Houston I have a problem!”

I said this in my opening post:

“I’m not counting ‘as yet unnamed man’ as I’m only looking for ratings of the named suspects.”

I’m pushing it by including BS man and Lawende’s man and Blotchy man to be honest as I did originally want this to be about named suspects but I don’t want to change it now.