Evidence to prove a suspect valid

[c.d.]

Hello CD. Thanks. You refer to Kate?

You cannot prove she was a prostitute any more than I can prove the converse.

But have you looked up the informal fallacy to which Errata referred? She is spot on.

Cheers.
LC

Hello Lynn,

As I have stated before, God himself could not convince you that any of these women were prostitutes.

As for Errata's post, while nicely argued, I think it is comparing apples to oranges. I will state my question again taken from an earlier post...why are we equating ANY knife murder of a woman to one where the woman was a prostitute and had her throat cut and her internal organs removed and there was no known motive? Even if you take out the prostitute requirement it is still a valid question.

And just for the record, I have never been aware that anyone who believes Jack killed the C5 has ever stated that he killed every single woman in Whitechapel.

c.d.

[GUT]

G'Day

And just for the record, I have never been aware that anyone who believes Jack killed the C5 has ever stated that he killed every single woman in Whitechapel.

AND I thought he killed everyone, everywhere for all time.

GUT

[c.d.]

G'Day




AND I thought he killed everyone, everywhere for all time.

GUT

Hello Gut,

Please don't say things like that. The anti-Jack crowd will pick up on it and use it in their posts when they want to be smart ass and sarcastic.

c.d.

[Tom_Wescott]

Hello CD. Thanks. You refer to Kate?

You cannot prove she was a prostitute any more than I can prove the converse.

But have you looked up the informal fallacy to which Errata referred? She is spot on.

Cheers.
LC

Well, there was a police officer who identified her as a prostitute.

Yours truly,

Tom Wescott

[Tom_Wescott]

Gimme a break. I almost never bust out Latin

No, but when you do, I will be waiting in the wings with some German.

Yours truly,

Tom Wescott

[GUT]

G'Day Tom and Errata

Gimme a break I barely speak English now I've gotta master Latin and German.

GUT

[Tom_Wescott]

G'Day Tom and Errata

Gimme a break I barely speak English now I've gotta master Latin and German.

GUT

You're safe, Gut. I exhausted my German in that first post. I'm hanging my hat on the hope she doesn't break out the Latin again until I can get Rosetta Stone.

Yours truly,

Tom Wescott

[GUT]

G'Day Tom

Thank you thank you thank you I had to look up gesundheit!


GUT

[GUT]

G'Day c.d.

Please don't say things like that. The anti-Jack crowd will pick up on it and use it in their posts when they want to be smart ass and sarcastic.

Sorry my bad

GUT

[lynn cates]

aspirin

Hello Errata. Thanks.

Precisely.

Incidentally, a colleague informed me that here is one birth control drug that
is 100% effective and contained in most households. Aspirin. She told me that taking one tablet and holding it between the knees always works.

Cheers.
LC

[GUT]

G'Day LC

Same thing mum always told my sisters.
Till big sis tried to prove her wrong.


GUT

[lynn cates]

removal

Hello CD. Thanks.

"And just for the record, I have never been aware that anyone who believes Jack killed the C5 has ever stated that he killed every single woman in Whitechapel."

Actually, I'd like it better if you did. makes MUCH more sense than the current enumeration system.

"why are we equating ANY knife murder of a woman to one where the woman was a prostitute and had her throat cut and her internal organs removed and there was no known motive?"

Umm, because that is how the question was posed. If you wish to eliminate those without organ removal, voila, there go Polly and Liz.

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

identified

Hello Tom. Thanks.

"Well, there was a police officer who identified her as a prostitute."

Indeed. And another copper claimed Piser was "Leather Apron."

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

failure

Hello GUT. Thanks.

Aspirin failure?

Cheers.
LC

[c.d.]

Hello Lynn,

You seem to be expending a lot of energy trying to knock down an argument that is not being made nor has it ever been made. I am not aware of anyone claiming that Jack was responsible for every single murder in Whitechapel.

c.d.