Decision

[Henry Flower]

Of course, but they can be employed constructively to arrive at an outcome which could be the correct one.

Herlock, let's hope his Ripperological suspect paperback won't be quite so plonkingly pedantic.

[Herlock Sholmes]

Of course, but they can be employed constructively to arrive at an outcome which could be the correct one.

[Pierre]

But 'what if's' and 'is it possible that..' are often employed to reach an outcome.

They are research questions. But they are not results.

[Mike J. G.]

Having read these forums quite a lot before joining, I've been amazed at how many people have been suckered in by the whole Pierre thing. He's probably coming up with a suspect now, but from the start he's just been pissing in the wind and enjoying the response. I don't blame him, it's worked a charm.

[John Wheat]

And Pierre does it again!

"I'm going to write a book - it will name my suspect but it's not a suspect book, because I'm not doing mere Ripperology, I'm a historian."

And from this asinine nonsense he gets 7 pages of comments from us.

Bravo Pierre.

Better than yet another thread on Lechmere the worst ever Ripper suspect though.

[Henry Flower]

And Pierre does it again!

"I'm going to write a book - it will name my suspect but it's not a suspect book, because I'm not doing mere Ripperology, I'm a historian."

And from this asinine nonsense he gets 7 pages of comments from us.

Bravo Pierre.

[Elamarna]

Have you ever seen Fandango? Its my favorite Costner movie. I believe his first leading role. Great movie-funny, moving, bittersweet dramedy.

No not seen it, guess will one day.

Steve

[Abby Normal]

Probably my favourite Costner movie.

Steve

Have you ever seen Fandango? Its my favorite Costner movie. I believe his first leading role. Great movie-funny, moving, bittersweet dramedy.

[Elamarna]

Field of Dreams is a pretty good movie IMHO.

Probably my favourite Costner movie.

Steve

[Elamarna]

I quite agree. How do we go about getting this bit of purely personal information from Pierre ("I'm writing a book" isn't suspect discussion) moved to its proper place?

Henry

I suggest the thread is in the correct place. Most reading this thread will see an upcoming publication naming a potential killer, the suspect area seems perfect for it.


Steve

[Abby Normal]

Field of Dreams is a pretty good movie IMHO.

[Elamarna]

Take your time Pierre, take your time.

Then perhaps I can get to read all the interesting stuff (like Steve's excellent Bucks Row Project) without having to pick my way through your rude, unhelpful & demeaning comments.

That is a very kind thing to say. There are mistakes in it of course some pointed out by Dusty and Gary, and those have been taken onboard.
My view is we sit back while Pierre gets on with his work. When he publishes we will either say "Yes of course its X" or faults will be found in it, either way we have something tangible to discuss.
And if nothing appears so be it.

I repeat what I said at the start of this thread, I wish Pierre well with his writing.

Steve

[Henry Flower]

Pub Talk would be the best place for it.

I quite agree. How do we go about getting this bit of purely personal information from Pierre ("I'm writing a book" isn't suspect discussion) moved to its proper place?

[ohrocky]

Take your time Pierre, take your time.

Then perhaps I can get to read all the interesting stuff (like Steve's excellent Bucks Row Project) without having to pick my way through your rude, unhelpful & demeaning comments.

[Harry D]

Pub Talk would be the best place for it.