Does The Killer Scope Out Locations Before He Kills?

[DJA]

Wasn't Parnell a pollie who,after 128 days of hearings,was found innocent?

[Michael W Richards]

There is nothing to link him to the case.

Maybe he had a music hall that required refurbishment.

Maybe he wished to sign up for Lusk's posse. They met in pubs and he was Irish.

His description fits no one seen at any of the canonical murders.

Why would he match any descriptions for other Canonicals, Im only dicussing Kates murder here.

[Michael W Richards]

Coincidentally, Queen Victoria reigned during the time of the murders....hmmmm.

c.d.

Lets not be flippant about the affects of Irish Self rule factions and the violent terrorist acts they planned and pulled off during those years. Terrorism was happening, at that time, and people who planned to do these acts were being paid by HMG, there was active planning going on to kill Balfour...and the commision was investigating complicity in targetted murders by a member of parliament...whether you choose to consider that when evaluating these murders is up to you.

[DJA]

Why would he match any descriptions for other Canonicals, Im only dicussing Kates murder here.

I shall seek Canadian interpreters.

[Michael W Richards]

Thats one big Canadian Flag...love it. Which reminds me.....today is Remembrance Day in Canada, sincere thanks to all those who serve their countries in the military.

[Vincenzo]

I've always been fascinated by the locations of the killings, as all of them with the exception of Nicholls in Buck's Row take place in broadened out areas which are arrived at through narrow passages. I thought the victims might have self-selected this way as they led their punter to these places. But now I'm wondering if it's possible that The Whitechapel Murderer is a lot more organized than he appears, and perhaps he did what a number of serials have done since, which is scout locations and check on them carefully before committing a murder there. If that's the case, then he would know about prostitutes taking their tricks to the backyard or 1st floor of 29 Hanbury Street. He would perhaps even know the customs of the people living in that house--what time they woke & went out to work etc etc. He may even have visited that back yard. He would know that the Club in Duffield's Yard was raucous and loud until late so that a killing in the shadows might not be overheard. He would know that the warehouse caretakers in Mitre Square didn't venture out at night and that few people were walking in that neighbourhood in the small hours. If Nicholls was the first, he didn't get what he was after. Sounds like he was disturbed probably by the guys who found the body. He may have decided to be more careful in future. And if so, it paid off for him. Which means he might be site-specific rather than victim-specific. He decides it's his night for fun. Hangs around his chosen location. Waits for someone to go--or totter--by. Says 'hallo'.

If that is the case then he would have been aware of the police patrol at Mitre Square and still took an incredible risk. That makes me believe he did not chose that spot ahead of time, either she led him there or it was unplanned as to where he was going to attack her and he just let it play out naturally.

[Michael W Richards]

If Jack was someone who usually operated in the East End then why would he have any knowledge of beat routines in Mitre Square on that, or any, night? I dont think the man that killed in Mitre Square needed or showed any specific street knowledge of the East End, but I think Polly and Annies did.

I believe Kates killer had to have been aware of the beats in the square that night. Just from watching Id guess.

[Michael W Richards]

If Jack was someone who usually operated in the East End then why would he have any knowledge of beat routines in Mitre Square on that, or any, night? I dont think the man that killed in Mitre Square needed or showed any specific street knowledge of the East End, but I think Polly and Annies did.

I believe Kates killer had to have been aware of the beats in the square that night. Just from watching Id guess.

No-one bites at this one? That in order for the killer in Mitre Square to have also been the man in the East end killings it would appear he let the situation develop wherever it happened in the East End but would have had to have beat information for city cops as well. Beats which changed nightly.

So is he Opportunity or Planning? Is Annies killing seemingly planned? Was Pollys?