How to make Ripperology better?

[Kaz]

All these posts just saying “ridiculous” are getting out of hand

ridiculous

[Scott Nelson]

Well I happen to love the Maybrick Diary. I think it's the greatest thing to ever smack Ripperology in the face.

[GUT]

All these posts just saying “ridiculous” are getting out of hand

[John Wheat]

Very good - you're catching on!

Ridiculous.

[Iconoclast]

Ridiculous.

Very good - you're catching on!

[John Wheat]

ridiculous

Ridiculous.

[Iconoclast]

Not very original are you?

ridiculous

[FISHY1118]

Hi FISHY,

I'm not sure I understand what it is that you were disputing here regarding the watch. It's hard enough to understand anything you write, so I concede I may have this all arse about face.

Were you claiming it to be 'pure fantasy' that the watch contains the carved [as in scratched or engraved] initials: MN, AC, ES, CE and MK, representing five of the Whitechapel murder victims?

Love,

Caz
X

Hi Caz , Ok ill try to explained it to you , the words ''Pure Fantasy was just in reference to the ''Belief'' that the initials belonged to the C5, not that some carvings made on the back of the watch didnt exist .I dont know how else to put it other than the phrase i used. Sorry just my opinion.

Im sorry that the way you interpreted my post was hard to understand.


I think your being a bit harse on the anything i write is hard to understand part , but hey ok, your call there. . Im not one for long drawn out post that say nothing and go nowhere.

Regards Fishy.

[NotBlamedForNothing]

off topic
here we go with the diary bs ad nauseum again-case in point re the title of this thread.

can you all please at least take this nonsense to the maybrick thread and stop clogging up casebook with crap?
Thanks in advance.

It's easy enough to redirect a thread that has gone off topic, to a more appropriate thread.

Just tap/click the ” Quote option for whatever ridiculous post you want to respond to, then copy & paste the result - the ridiculous post, surrounded by QUOTE tags - into the appropriate thread. Then, obviously, add your reply.

[John Wheat]

[QUOTE=Iconoclast;n785715]

What a totally ridiculous comment.

Not very original are you?

[Iconoclast]

[QUOTE=John Wheat;n785706]

What a totally ridiculous comment.

What a totally ridiculous comment.

[C. F. Leon]

Sorry, Jonathan. I didn't notice that you had already posted something similar until after I had sent mine.

[C. F. Leon]

... Can we return to the question at hand? ...

The "question at hand" as I recall it, is "How to make Ripperology better?", not yet ANOTHER argument about the Maybrick Diary, which already has PLENTY of threads and even a separate section of its own that you can post all you want on.

Please keep to stated topic.

[jmenges]

Please keep Maybrick debates on Maybrick threads.
God knows there’s plenty of them to choose from.

JM

[John Wheat]

off topic
here we go with the diary bs ad nauseum again-case in point re the title of this thread.

can you all please at least take this nonsense to the maybrick thread and stop clogging up casebook with crap?
Thanks in advance.

I'm just pointing out how ridiculous the idea that the diary is written by Maybrick when it was clearly written by Mike Barrett is.