found this looking for a bobbie book ?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
lifes a game
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Ms Diddles View Post
Sorry Milchman!
I'm not sure what this means.
Are you saying you're on Team Maybrick?
why ?
also like Bruce Robinsons take on the diary ,
could well believe it having been the youngest of four brothers ,
as Arnie says " **** happens ".
Comment
-
Originally posted by milchmanuk View Post
50/.50 i read the books but not the transcript as yet of the diary contents,
why ?
also like Bruce Robinsons take on the diary ,
could well believe it having been the youngest of four brothers ,
as Arnie says " **** happens ".
I'm sure Iconoclast and erobitha would be glad to have you aboard.
I like the Bruce Robinson book too.
I'm not convinced by his conclusion, but it's a hell of a read and I like his writing.
I love Withnail & I, so I was always going to be well disposed to that one.
- Likes 2
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ms Diddles View Post
Fair enough!
I'm sure Iconoclast and erobitha would be glad to have you aboard.
I like the Bruce Robinson book too.
I'm not convinced by his conclusion, but it's a hell of a read and I like his writing.
I love Withnail & I, so I was always going to be well disposed to that one.
Comment
-
Originally posted by milchmanuk View Post
the three i like are Kosminski /Lechmere and the Maybrick brothers' , all good yarns but common sense says we're not going to know , JTR once shown to walk through a door and passage way probably felt obliged to do so more often when leaving crime scenes, this is all i got to on thoughts this week.
Of the named ones I favour Bury, Koz and Druitt (duck and cover!!), but yeah I agree we are probably never going to know.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ms Diddles View Post
Personally I lean towards unknown (probably local) man.
Of the named ones I favour Bury, Koz and Druitt (duck and cover!!), but yeah I agree we are probably never going to know.
and thank god for spell correct other wise it read like Lusks letter SOR
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ms Diddles View Post
Fair enough!
I'm sure Iconoclast and erobitha would be glad to have you aboard.
I like the Bruce Robinson book too.
I'm not convinced by his conclusion, but it's a hell of a read and I like his writing.
I love Withnail & I, so I was always going to be well disposed to that one.
Milkmen in the UK and other countries are welcome to join the ranks of the Maybrick believers if they wish but - word to the wise, buddy - it's probably going to be a rather unsatisfying and rocky road.
The more the merrier though!
PS If it was Edwin - the youngest brother - there would need to be some sort of evidence in favour of it. Ol' Brucey's They All Love Jack is off the scale for erudition and research and I can't fault it other than to say that Soothsayer's Razor says cut out the middlestory (that Jack the Ripper hoaxed the Victorian scrapbook) and just stick with James the Ripper instead.
Ike
Comment
Comment