If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Thank you. It was lovely. And I have liked McLean's singing and songs since his "American Pie" and "Vincent" (one of my favorites) came out in the 1970s.
My favorite Scottish patriot tune (of recent times) was "There Was a Soldier".
A very rough copy, but here's me singing Michael Marra's "Hamish". The song is about Hamish McAlpine, the inspiring goalkeeper for Michael's beloved Dundee United during their peak years in the Scotti
Thank you. It was lovely. And I have liked McLean's singing and songs since his "American Pie" and "Vincent" (one of my favorites) came out in the 1970s.
My favorite Scottish patriot tune (of recent times) was "There Was a Soldier".
Jeff
Wrong MacLean, Jeff! 'Caledonia' is by a genuine Scot called Dougie MacLean
and is a standard at just about every folk-club in the UK! It really a great song, though.
And you know what Dr Johnson said about 'patriotism'.....
Graham
We are suffering from a plethora of surmise, conjecture and hypothesis. - Sherlock Holmes, The Adventure Of Silver Blaze
Wrong MacLean, Jeff! 'Caledonia' is by a genuine Scot called Dougie MacLean
and is a standard at just about every folk-club in the UK! It really a great song, though.
And you know what Dr Johnson said about 'patriotism'.....
Graham
I may have a bad eye and a tin ear then, Graham, he looked like the same man. But it was a pretty song.
"The last refuge of a scoundrel." Yes I heard Dr. Johnson's definition and epigram. It was trounced a little by Ambrose Bierce (calling Johnson a distinguished but inferior lexicographer), and saying that it actually is the first refuge. Witness the buffoon entering the White House and his choices for cabinet and similar posts. Bierce and Johnson are correct.
I may have a bad eye and a tin ear then, Graham, he looked like the same man. But it was a pretty song.
"The last refuge of a scoundrel." Yes I heard Dr. Johnson's definition and epigram. It was trounced a little by Ambrose Bierce (calling Johnson a distinguished but inferior lexicographer), and saying that it actually is the first refuge. Witness the buffoon entering the White House and his choices for cabinet and similar posts. Bierce and Johnson are correct.
Jeff
Easy mistake-a to make-a!
Johnson didn't mean to be complimentary either to 'scoundrels' or to 'patriotism'. And in fairness to Johnson, who I always admired, I think his name is remembered somewhat more than Ambrose Bierce's.
Graham
We are suffering from a plethora of surmise, conjecture and hypothesis. - Sherlock Holmes, The Adventure Of Silver Blaze
Johnson didn't mean to be complimentary either to 'scoundrels' or to 'patriotism'. And in fairness to Johnson, who I always admired, I think his name is remembered somewhat more than Ambrose Bierce's.
Graham
Recognize that (Johnson also made that cutting remark about "oats", horses, and Scots). The good Doctor must have been a fascinating man, but a bit strong regarding his viewpoints. He made a really interesting comment on the American "revolt" of the 1770s, and how fascinating it was that so many men wanted more liberty but kept slaves. Good point.
You are right, Johnson is better remembered than Bierce (despite the latter's mysterious end in Mexico). However, in Bierce's own mind - well that was an entirely different matter.
Comment