Originally posted by Natalie Severn
View Post
No, I disagree, I think Sherrard was smart enough to realise it does apply to all identification witnesses, which is why he deliberately phrased it the way he did - hence you had to add in "[-referring to Valerie Storie"s statement]" in post #7587.
By raising the more general point about other witness statements you are failing to appraise each of their statements in context.
and she composed an identikit picture that looked nothing like Hanratty but was the image of Alphon!
Blackhall composed the other image---and is on record as saying the man Skillett and he saw looked nothing like Hanratty.
KR,
Vic.
Comment