HELP I need some new books - Recommendations?

[Graham]

Hi Louisa,

The old man Gaston Dominici was tried and found guilty and was later pardoned by DeGaulle, but only because of his age - he was over 80 by this time and had spent a long time in jail already. He certainly wasn't pardoned because of any doubt about his guilt.

In fact there was, and is, a good deal of doubt about his guilt. There were many questions raised concerning the police investigation and also the conduct of his trial. Note that Dominici was never pardoned nor was there ever a re-trial. To this day surviving members of his family still campaign that he was innocent.

The murder of the Drummond family is eerily similar to the murder in France of Professor John Cartland 20 years later.

Graham

PS: have you read anything about the Rode Hill Murder, as per 'The Suspicions Of Mr Whicher'? That's a case that was never really laid to rest.

[John G]

I've just remembered another excellent true crime book: Jack of Jumps, by David Seabrook, an immensely detailed investigation into the Jack the Stripper murders. Apparently Seabrook was "accidentally" given access to the official police records, even though they have not yet been released. However, one caveat: Seabrook appears to show little sympathy for the victims, and some of his language is a little unfortunate to say the least.

Nonetheless, for detailed analysis it's one of the best crime fiction books that I've read.

I could also recommend Wicked Beyond Belief: The Hunt for the Yorkshire Ripper, by Michael Bilton, another highly detailed work that also contains transcripts of the original police interviews.

[barnflatwyngarde]

I can heartily recommend "The Burning of Evelyn Foster" by Jonathan Goodman.
It is an excellent dissection of a truly strange case.

In the realm of JTR, I can recommend "Jack the Ripper: The Definitive Casebook" by Richard Whittington Egan.
It is as if you are sitting across from a knowledgeable old uncle as he discusses all aspects of the case, with some gentle barbs lobbed at certain authors that have failed to live up the rigorous standards that RWE expects.

Absolutely wonderful!

[louisa]

Wow! Thank you all so much for your help. I'll be going on Amazon shortly to purchase some of those recommended books, some of the cases sound very interesting indeed.

I already have books on quite a few of the cases mentioned. The Bamber case is one I know backwards.

Getting back to the Dominici Affair, the Annecy case was only similar in that a family were murdered in France. As I recall didn't the brother turn out to be the guilty one, albeit not proven?

I have the orson Welles video of the Dominici Affair in my collection but I certainly would not recommend it. It's rambling and boring and time seems to stand still when you're watching it. There is another video of the case which is a lot better. My video is untitled but I recorded it from a TV documentary on the Crime and Investigation channel a few years ago. They were running a series about interesting murders from the past. It's much much more detailed than the Orson Welles effort.

The old man Gaston Dominici was tried and found guilty and was later pardoned by DeGaulle, but only because of his age - he was over 80 by this time and had spent a long time in jail already. He certainly wasn't pardoned because of any doubt about his guilt.

I have no doubt about it either but I'm certain that his son was also involved; he certainly moved the bodies in his search for......what? A camera maybe? The one the little girl was taking photos with shortly before she died? The camera was never found.


Regarding other murders - I already have the book about the Charles Bravo case, and very good it is too.

Somebody on this forum (a long time ago) was talking about the case of Mr. Briggs' Hat - a murder I'd never heard of before. I bought the book and it was a very good read. So being on this forum is helping me a lot.


For others interested in these type of crimes I would recommend this one:

"The Murder At Wrotham Hill" by Diana Souhami

Please keep the recommendations coming because I'm finding them very very useful. Thanks so much!

[Caligo Umbrator]

Hi, louisa.

I offer a few more suggestions from my shelf.

'The London Monster' by 'Jan Bondeson',(2002).

The 'London Monster' was the name given to the perpetrator of a series of around fifty physical assaults against females in seventeen ninety. The author reviews these in detail, covers the capture and trial of the supposed offender and considers the related hysteria that briefly engulfed Londoners that year. He further explores other similar but later cases of 'phantom' or 'monster' attacks and collective frenzy. Well illustrated and with twenty pages of references and notes.

'Four Against the Bank of England' by 'Ann Huxley',(1969).

True crime, Hustle style. Deceit, fraud, and forgery are the tools in trade of four men who take the Bank of England to the cleaners in Victorian Britain. An extraordinary tale containing equal measures of audaciousness and gullibility.

'Lord High Executioner' by 'Howard Engel',(1996).

Not true crime so much as a somewhat potted account of the fate that those found guilty of a truly heinous crime might end up suffering, as execution methods through the ages changed. The differing means by which the prisoner met their final release is examined in sometimes dreadful detail. Illustrated with documents, tables, and photographs. Good bibliography and index.

'Murder Guide to London' by 'Martin Fido',(1986).

A useful 'murder digest', comprising of a short, one to three-page description of the characters involved, the commission of the crime (or crimes) and the final consequences for those concerned. Packed with interesting stories and, in each case, one is furnished with all the relevant and required information. As well as containing appealing photographs, there are also included, towards the rear of the book, some helpful 'A-Z' style maps, showing the locations of the incidents, allowing the reader to develop their own 'murder tour' should they wish.

Mayerling mentioned 'Manhunt', a title by 'James Swanson'. Should that subject be of interest, there is another book by Swanson entitled 'Bloody Crimes', which more or less picks up the threads of the previous book and tells the joint stories of Lincoln's final journey and the hunt for the Confederate President, Jefferson Davis. A colourful, dramatic and poignant tale.


Yours, Caligo

[Billiou]

The Murders at White House Farm by Carol Ann Lee
An account of the 1985 murders of the Bamber family.

[Caligo Umbrator]

Hi, louisa.

Here are a few that I have on my shelf and recommend.
Not arranged in any particular order.

'Murder by Gaslight' by 'Leonard Piper',(1991). Ten murder cases from the Victorian and Edwardian periods, each case taking up a compact twenty or so pages but delivering plenty of intrigue and detail. Unhappily lacking a bibliography or index.

'Unsolved Murders in Victorian and Edwardian London' by 'Jonathan Oates',(2007). Twenty-five cases, an introductory chapter on policing in the Capital during the relevant periods and a few useful notes on Londons changing population and that awkward old monetary system. With index and bibliography listing primary and secondary sources.

'An Edward Pearson True Crime Reader, Masterpieces of Murder' Edited by 'Gerald Gross',(1963). A compilation of classic essays and articles by the crime writer Edward Pearson(1880-1937).

'Victorian Murderesses' by 'Mary S. Hartman',(1977). A somewhat dry but well-researched work, detailing the lives of thirteen murderesses. Rather than a plain retelling of old stories, the author examines the morals and prejudices of the times, giving a fuller understanding of the social pressures and restrictions women faced every day. Comprehensive notes and bibliography.

'The Murder of Helen Jewett' by 'Patricia Cline Cohen',(1998).
Extensive and engrossing account of the life and death of a prostitute in early nineteenth-century New York and the subsequent trial and acquittal of a suspect. Well illustrated with maps, letters, and portraits and containing over forty pages of detailed notes.

'The Blooding' by 'Joseph Wambaugh',(1989).
A riveting account of the nineteen-eighties police investigation into the murders of two young girls in neighbouring English villages. It details the first use of DNA fingerprinting and its part in revealing the identity of the murderer.

Yours, Caligo.

[Mayerling]

Hi, Louisa.

Here is a link to a selection of books about serial killers, mostly in the 20th century.

http://www.the-line-up.com/8-disturbing-books-about-serial-killers/

I don't know how good any of those titles are, though I did read one book about the BTK killer which was very frightening.

My favorite true crime book is Erik Larson's The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair that Changed America.
https://www.amazon.com/Devil-White-C...=UTF8&qid=&sr=
This book combines the history of the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago with H. H. Holmes's "murder hotel", also in Chicago and in operation at the same time. It's very readable and quite fascinating.

Larson also wrote "Thunderstruck" which is about Marconi's struggles to create "wireless telegraphy" from 1899 to 1910, and the parallel story of Dr. Hawley Harvey Crippen and the murder of his wife Cora, whose capture with his mistress Ethel Le Neve fleeing to Canada on the "S.S. Montrose", was due to the use of wireless.

Also I recommend Edwards Stears' "Blood on the Moon", an excellent in depth retelling of the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. Also James Swanson wrote a terrific account of the national response in searching for John Wilkes Booth, named "Manhunt".

Jeff

[Pcdunn]

Hi, Louisa.

Here is a link to a selection of books about serial killers, mostly in the 20th century.

http://www.the-line-up.com/8-disturbing-books-about-serial-killers/

I don't know how good any of those titles are, though I did read one book about the BTK killer which was very frightening.

My favorite true crime book is Erik Larson's The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair that Changed America.
https://www.amazon.com/Devil-White-C...=UTF8&qid=&sr=
This book combines the history of the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago with H. H. Holmes's "murder hotel", also in Chicago and in operation at the same time. It's very readable and quite fascinating.

[Graham]

Hi Louisa,

Somebody was brought to book for the murder of the Drummonds. A local man whose pride was hurt by this posh English family who camped on (what he considered to be) his land.

I think there was a leeeetle bit more to it than that; but I won't be a spoilsport.

Dominici was actually pardoned by Presidential decree, an extremely rare occurrence in France, and questions have been asked with regard to how much certain persons in high office knew about this case.

Just to whet your appetite and maybe set you thinking, how much do you know - or even, have you heard? - of the Cartland Case of 1973?

Graham

[John G]

Hi Louisa,

I can definitely recommend Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery, by Robert Kolker. The book examines the possibility of a Long Island serial killer, with a particular focus on the lives of the victims, and was described by the New York Times as "Riveting and Heartbreaking." I completely agree.

I could also recommend a couple of e-books that I've read recently: Move to Murder, an exhaustive examination of the intriguing Wallace murder, and Poisoning at the Priory, a nineteenth century mystery concerning the poisoning of Charles Bravo. Was it suicide, murder or a case of misadventure?

With both of these books you can go onto a website-Cold Case Jury-and vote for your preferred solution, after which you can access the author's own conclusions.

[Mayerling]

Interesting case - Orson Welles got involved in it too. He was in France at the time, raising money for his own films, and was doing a series on French television, and he went to the local of the Drummond murders, and interviewed people involved in the case. It was for his television show, and the French government clamped down on what he was doing. If you look up Welles or Dominici on "You Tube" (and understand French) you can see the surviving film he shot.

Jeff

[louisa]

Hi Graham,

Thanks for your reply.

Somebody was brought to book for the murder of the Drummonds. A local man whose pride was hurt by this posh English family who camped on (what he considered to be) his land.

I'm not spoiling the story because this lovable old Frenchman is the prime suspect right from the start - but proving it? And what about the pathetic attempts by his large family to cover up for him?

His grandson Alain (now grown up of course) is all for the idiotic conspiracy theory, which in my opinion, is frankly ridiculous. Just because Drummond was a scientist he has to also have been a spy - on a secret mission - and using his family as a smoke screen!

They were simply an English family having a wonderful motoring holiday in the south of France and picked the wrong place to camp.

The detective was heroic imo and laid the truth bare.

Fascinating stuff!

[Robert]

Fiction, and not a book, but worth mentioning :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pCgHSMHP7hg

[Joshua Rogan]

Crikey. I'd not heard of the Dominici Affair before, but the basic details - British scientist and family holidaying in France found shot in a lay by - sound remarkably like the Annecy murders of a few years ago.