Ripperologist 160

[Sam Flynn]

Thanks, Stephen

[cnr]

Thanks Abby, I'm glad you enjoyed it and I take on board those aspects of the piece which particularly spoke to you and dovetail with your own suspicions.

From my perspective, the issue which really hit home was that the two Toppy signatures (1898 and 1911) remained remarkably constant over 13 years. We might say that they are near replicas of each other. But when they are compared to the witness samples from 1888 there's something fundamentally not right - for all that the time elapsed at their nearest comparison is down to 10 years.

Which brings up another tangential consideration. If we accept Iremonger's basic contention, then how damn good was she, encircling the Toppy salient with a single pincer: she was going off only one example of his signature !

BTW, thanks to Gareth and Adam for going with the article, and the very nice presentation of another edition.

And happy posting to you, Abby. Always good to know you're on the case.

Stephen

https://www.timesofisrael.com/were-the-jack-the-ripper-murders-an-elaborate-anti-semitic-frameup/

[Abby Normal]

great article by Stephen Sinise on the Hutch sigs. I always thought they were probably different, but this nails the deal for me. Toppy wasn't the witness hutch.

When you generally compare them they just look different. Specifically though the G seals the deal for me. They are totally different. and the fact that its the first letter of the first name is significant because that usually dosnt change (or as much) as other letters in the name. My sig has changed over the years but the capital first letter of my first name (as well as the first letter of my last) has remained the same for 40 years.

No question in my mind these are two very different sigs and different men.

great work again Stephen!!

[GUT]

Thank you got mine this morning

[jmenges]

Contents include:

EDITORIAL:
CHANGING FASTER NOT BETTER?
Adam Wood

THE WELSHMAN WHO KNEW MARY KELLY
Paul Williams

GEORGE WILLIAM TOPPING HUTCHINSON: ‘TOPPY’
Stephen Senise

FROM RIPPER SUSPECT TO HYPERPEDESTRIAN:
THE STRANGE CAREER OF BERESFORD GREATHEAD
Jan Bondeson

LULU - THE EIGHTH WONDER OF THE WORLD
Heather Tweed

WOMAN’S WORK: AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF CAPTURING THE WHITECHAPEL MURDERER
PART TWO
Nina and Howard Brown

VICTORIAN FICTION: THE WITHERED ARM
By Thomas Hardy

THE LATEST BOOK REVIEWS
By Paul Begg and David Green

***

To subscribe to Ripperologist Magazine send an email to contact@ripperologist.biz

JM