May I just add something here ?
Despite the minor syntax errors ( minor in that we all knew what Craig meant without hammering on his Minnesota head too hard.... ), we ought to appreciate the fact that he isn't ducking or dodging any criticism of his article in this very fine issue of RN. Some authors do avoid discussion of their work when its challenged.
To me, it seems like the punishment doesn't fit the "crime". Just an opinion.
Despite the minor syntax errors ( minor in that we all knew what Craig meant without hammering on his Minnesota head too hard.... ), we ought to appreciate the fact that he isn't ducking or dodging any criticism of his article in this very fine issue of RN. Some authors do avoid discussion of their work when its challenged.
To me, it seems like the punishment doesn't fit the "crime". Just an opinion.
Comment