Leather Apron, Jack the Ripper, and the Whitechapel Murders

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • The Station Cat
    Premium Member
    • Mar 2016
    • 641

    #1

    Leather Apron, Jack the Ripper, and the Whitechapel Murders

    Has anyone read this book?

    What did you think?

    Is it something new or just the same old blurb regurgitated?

    I'm looking for another "The Bank Holiday Murders" by Tom Wescott, will this do the trick?
  • GUT
    Commissioner
    • Jan 2014
    • 7841

    #2
    Not even close.
    G U T

    There are two ways to be fooled, one is to believe what isn't true, the other is to refuse to believe that which is true.

    Comment

    • Tom_Wescott
      Commissioner
      • Feb 2008
      • 6996

      #3
      Originally posted by The Station Cat View Post
      Has anyone read this book?

      What did you think?

      Is it something new or just the same old blurb regurgitated?

      I'm looking for another "The Bank Holiday Murders" by Tom Wescott, will this do the trick?
      Ripper Confidential has a similar writing style to Bank Holiday Murders. Same level of brilliance. However, while I suspect the author has little trouble getting dates with the ladies, calendrical dates are said not to be his strong point. Or topography. Definitely not topography. But these are very minor quibbles and I doubt anyone else is likely to notice. On the whole, Ripper Confidential is the best book ever written on any subject ever in the whole of the world.

      I just called Tom to ask him if any Mike Covell books were similar in quality to his own. After I asked there was this shrill, inhuman noise, like if Satan sat on a running chainsaw or something, and then the line went dead. We must have had a bad connection. So, I'd probably just trust your GUT on this one.

      Yours truly,

      Joe Boggs

      Comment

      • The Station Cat
        Premium Member
        • Mar 2016
        • 641

        #4
        Originally posted by Tom_Wescott View Post
        Ripper Confidential has a similar writing style to Bank Holiday Murders. Same level of brilliance. However, while I suspect the author has little trouble getting dates with the ladies, calendrical dates are said not to be his strong point. Or topography. Definitely not topography. But these are very minor quibbles and I doubt anyone else is likely to notice. On the whole, Ripper Confidential is the best book ever written on any subject ever in the whole of the world.

        I just called Tom to ask him if any Mike Covell books were similar in quality to his own. After I asked there was this shrill, inhuman noise, like if Satan sat on a running chainsaw or something, and then the line went dead. We must have had a bad connection. So, I'd probably just trust your GUT on this one.

        Yours truly,

        Joe Boggs








        Thanks Tom ermm I mean Joe.



        But in all seriousness, is this book worth picking up?

        Comment

        • martin wilson
          Detective
          • Jan 2010
          • 407

          #5
          It's mostly a collection of contemporary newspaper reports of the time about leather apron.
          It's a great resource but very repetitive, I'm not entirely sure what the point was in repeating the same article from different newspapers but it wore me down and I started skimming.
          It might have been better to show where newspaper reports deviated from the text significantly enough to merit attention.
          Still, only 99p on offer from Amazon. And for anyone interested in the whole John Pizer business will find much to occupy them.
          I feel a bit guilty about the 99p price, I doubt many ripper authors are coining it in. Apart from Trev, who I reckon is well minted.

          Comment

          • Trevor Marriott
            Commissioner
            • Feb 2008
            • 9463

            #6
            Originally posted by martin wilson View Post
            It's mostly a collection of contemporary newspaper reports of the time about leather apron.
            It's a great resource but very repetitive, I'm not entirely sure what the point was in repeating the same article from different newspapers but it wore me down and I started skimming.
            It might have been better to show where newspaper reports deviated from the text significantly enough to merit attention.
            Still, only 99p on offer from Amazon. And for anyone interested in the whole John Pizer business will find much to occupy them.
            I feel a bit guilty about the 99p price, I doubt many ripper authors are coining it in. Apart from Trev, who I reckon is well minted.
            If I had your money I would burn mine

            Comment

            • RockySullivan
              Chief Inspector
              • Feb 2014
              • 1914

              #7
              Originally posted by martin wilson View Post
              It's mostly a collection of contemporary newspaper reports of the time about leather apron.
              It's a great resource but very repetitive, I'm not entirely sure what the point was in repeating the same article from different newspapers but it wore me down and I started skimming.
              It might have been better to show where newspaper reports deviated from the text significantly enough to merit attention.
              Still, only 99p on offer from Amazon. And for anyone interested in the whole John Pizer business will find much to occupy them.
              I feel a bit guilty about the 99p price, I doubt many ripper authors are coining it in. Apart from Trev, who I reckon is well minted.
              thanks i'm actually looking for more books like this that are all newspaper articles

              Comment

              • Sam Flynn
                Casebook Supporter
                • Feb 2008
                • 13332

                #8
                Originally posted by RockySullivan View Post
                thanks i'm actually looking for more books like this that are all newspaper articles
                There seems to have been a rash of similarly padded books in recent years, mostly of the self published variety.
                Kind regards, Sam Flynn

                "Suche Nullen" (Nietzsche, Götzendämmerung, 1888)

                Comment

                • RockySullivan
                  Chief Inspector
                  • Feb 2014
                  • 1914

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Sam Flynn View Post
                  There seems to have been a rash of similarly padded books in recent years, mostly of the self published variety.
                  The only ones I can find are by Mike Covell and i'm not even positive which are newspaper press reports. I think it's a great service because I love reading newspapers reports don't like doing it on the computer

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X