Sorry, Sugden

[George Hutchinson]

Stephen's right. This system needs changing. I'm astounded (but maybe I shouldn't be) that Trenouth spent so much time voting for herself again and again and again. Even with her fake reviews, she limited herself to half a dozen. I bet she gave herself a vote every single day she turned her PC on as a matter of course.

This needs to be wiped and started again with only Casebook Members allowed to vote.

Maybe Rob and I might feature, even if only at the bottom!

PHILIP

[Kelly]

Sadder thing is, she's probably going around touting the fact that she has the highest-rated book on casebook.

[George Hutchinson]

...to all her multiple personalities.

PHILIP

[Mike Covell]

Sadder thing is, she's probably going around touting the fact that she has the highest-rated book on casebook.

And to Chief Chewenbacca!

[joelhall]

what about having to include a short review in order to vote? just to explain your vote, bit like ebay feedback?

joel

[DVV]

Karen's books are through the roof despite being historically some of the worst material ever written, Sophie's French book is extremely high, a book I've never even heard of published by the vanity press company LuLu by someone named Maurice Lipton somehow ranks #13, and so forth and so on.

Hello Dan and all,
I'm lost here...What's that new book??? Karen-Kelly??? Is it possible to be more stupid than Sophie's??? Completely flabbergasted here...
Shouldn't you create a special annual Award ceremony for such things?
The Plastic Knife Award?

[Dan Norder]

I don't read French, so I have to go by what others tell me of Sophie's work, but my feeling is that Karen Trenouth's books are probably worse.

[DVV]

O'right Dan,
if you are interested, just give me some days, and I will email you a detailed review of it, almost chapter by chapter, with the main "arguments".
Prepare yourself to a GREAT SHOCK!
Then you will decide who deserves the Plastic Knife!
A sample?
...
Oh my Lord (Ahura Mazda) I can't make my choice...!

[Suzi]

Hi all
Considering the worldwide kerfuffle that Trenouth's 'offerings' caused (quite rightly!) I haven't heard a wimper re Sophie's.......... looks like we've got a treat in store though c/o DVV !!

Suz x

[DVV]

Hello Suzi,
I don't know about "the satanic team", though the title tells me a lot...
Regarding Sophie's book, I just can say I couldn't believe my eyes.
So, some samples (I'm writing quickly because I have problems with my connection this week):
One of the best: after Chapman's murder, Sophie writes that there were footprints of "indian-type" shoes in the rear-yard (???!!!), which proves that it was Macnaghten's shoes, since he had lived in India!!!
Shall I mention that the scarf around Chapman's neck indicates that the murderer is a worshipper of Kali?
Another?
Do you know about "Jack the Tarpauliner"?
Cross and Paul discovered the corpse under a tarpaulin (misunderstood of Cross statement:"at first, I thought it was a tarpaulin..." etc). On French TV she even mimed the scene, pulling an imaginary tarpaulin!
I could go ahead, but what's the purpose? There is everything, false quotations, false translations...
As a last example, Suzi, remember the letter Polly wrote to his father when she started working for the Cowdrys. Sophie states she was in Lambeth Workhouse, and happy to say: "Some people left yesterday, so I could be admitted..."
Can't this challenge the Satanic Team?
Amitiés
David

[Dan Norder]

Hi David,

OK, you have a contender for a book that might be worse than the Karen Trenouth ones. I guess the English-speaking world is lucky that one isn't well known. It's not like we need any more bizarre and nonsensical theories with how many are already out there.

But, for comparison sake, Karen looks at the photo of Mary Kelly's room with the close up of her body and the flesh on the table and decides she sees a statue of Baphomet there and invents up some vast conspiracy of Satanists and Freemasons, etc. That's almost as wacky as the idea that Tumblety was a Satanist/Freemason/Templar/terrorist working with W.T. Stead, which at least thankfully never made it into a book and only gets bandied around the Internet.

[DVV]

I'm about to go to court and ask my 20 euros back...