Why wasn't her uterus taken?

[Barnaby]

Matter is neither created nor destroyed. So assuming the coroner's report is accurate (and given the meticulous accounting of the organs I suspect it is on this point), the heart was absent. This leaves three possibilities:

1. The Ripper took it with him (perhaps because he was a responsible and loving dog owner this whole time and has been terribly misunderstood for 125+ years )
2. The Ripper ate it (a variant of #1 but a variant certainly worth noting!)
3. The Ripper burned it to ashes in the fire (or cooked it and then ate it).

Given his signature, I suspect #1 (minus dog) is most likely although for some reason I can't explain I'm partial to burning it to ashes in the fire.

Regarding cannibalism, the doss houses where he may have stayed had community kitchens, no? He wouldn't be the first serial killer to serve up human flesh to unsuspecting folk. Purely speculative, but this kind of freaks me out.

If this were a copy cat crime it would nicely explain why Joe/Hutch/Flemming would take the wrong organ. But I think that this was done by the same gent who killed the other canonicals.

[Fisherman]

Hello Christer.

"Nichols? Shock value? Nah - she was lying gently stretched out on the pavement, her abdominal wounds carefully hidden from sight.
Her killer did not want to shock with that deed, apparently."

What's this? We agree? Ah!

Cheers.
LC

There´s shock value for you, Lynn!

The best,
Fisherman

[GUT]

G'day c.d.

He also might have thought that lighting a fire, in addition to giving him light in which to work, might make passersby think that Mary was with someone and so they wouldn't want to disturb her.

c.d.

Or Mary may have lit it before going out so the room would be nice and cozy to get down to business.

[c.d.]

He also might have thought that lighting a fire, in addition to giving him light in which to work, might make passersby think that Mary was with someone and so they wouldn't want to disturb her.

c.d.

[c.d.]

Or perhaps he was confident enough [deranged enough] that he felt he could easily deal with anyone who arrived.

After all people enter occupied houses all the time to commit crimes, at times killing anyone who disturbs them.

Hello Gut,

Yeah, that was probably his plan. Brandish his knife and run out the door before anybody had time to react.

c.d.

[GUT]

Or perhaps he was confident enough [deranged enough] that he felt he could easily deal with anyone who arrived.

After all people enter occupied houses all the time to commit crimes, at times killing anyone who disturbs them.

[c.d.]

This is kind of gross but I wonder if he could have eaten Mary's heart while he was still in her room.

c.d.

[lynn cates]

In a spot of difficulty.

Hello Colin.

"Did he know how much time he had? If anyone entered the room while he was at work he was at least as trapped as he would be in the darkness of a back-alley, arguably more so. How could the killer know there would be no interruption?"

"Blast! Who's that? Right. So, Mr. Barnett, yes, I DO know what this looks like, but I can explain everything."

Cheers.
LC

[c.d.]

Did he know how much time he had? If anyone entered the room while he was at work he was at least as trapped as he would be in the darkness of a back-alley, arguably more so. How could the killer know there would be no interruption? Kelly had, until recently, had a live-in lover and even more recently had had another woman sharing at least the room, if not the bed.
I surmise that Kelly's killer was probably known to her because the circumstances suggest (to me anyway) that he had some awareness of her personal circumstances.

I think he was known to her as well but even someone she had met earlier in the day or week falls into that category. A few drinks might have loosened her tongue and she might have given away personal information without realizing it.

c.d.

[lynn cates]

Fido

Hello Boris.

"He did it for Fido."

Martin Fido, of course? (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

How offal!

Hello Colin.

"Perhaps he had a dog to feed? The organs weren't visually identifiable as of human origin. Offal is offal and it wasn't in short supply in an area which housed numerous abattoirs and butcher's shops."

Or perhaps he was "butchering a sheep" and taking the parts to market?

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

agreement

Hello Christer.

"Nichols? Shock value? Nah - she was lying gently stretched out on the pavement, her abdominal wounds carefully hidden from sight.
Her killer did not want to shock with that deed, apparently."

What's this? We agree? Ah!

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

punctus contra punctum

Hello Harry. Thanks.

"1. Can this truly be disputed?"

Absolutely. And time and again.

"2. Most serial killers have an urge to kill that rarely stops of its own accord. It is somewhat speculative that Jack couldn't have killed more prostitutes indoors, which is why I raised the question in my last post."

Why are we assuming a serial killer here?

"3. I believe the nature of Jack's killings were opportunistic in nature. I don't believe there was a great deal of planning behind them, with the possible exception of MJK."

I think Kate was the most planned of all.

"Not unless he was disrupted before he could finish the deed?"

Deus ex machina?

Cheers.
LC

[Bridewell]

Hello Lynn,

Could that not be explained by circumstance? The killer had MJK all to himself in a relatively secure location. He wasn't fumbling around in the darkness of a back-alley, where someone could come around the corner at any moment.

Did he know how much time he had? If anyone entered the room while he was at work he was at least as trapped as he would be in the darkness of a back-alley, arguably more so. How could the killer know there would be no interruption? Kelly had, until recently, had a live-in lover and even more recently had had another woman sharing at least the room, if not the bed.
I surmise that Kelly's killer was probably known to her because the circumstances suggest (to me anyway) that he had some awareness of her personal circumstances.

[bolo]

Perhaps he had a dog to feed? The organs weren't visually identifiable as of human origin. Offal is offal and it wasn't in short supply in an area which housed numerous abattoirs and butcher's shops.

Now that's an explanation. He did it for Fido.