The Poor Victims - Injuries

[Fiver]

Ah no, please allow me to clarify...

I was referring to the idea that because the killer took MJK's heart through a means by which only a person with knowledge of where and how to cut and remove; I am suggesting the possibility that the reason why he knew how wasn't because he was necessarily a skilled surgical physician but rather; he had cut into women many, MANY times before; ergo, the Torso killer would have had some knowledge of how to cut, remove and dismember.
I believe it is the only way to explain how such an advanced technique was implemented with Kelly.

I'm other words I don't believe he was a therotically assured surgeon with anatomical knowledge gathered through learning surgical techniques, but rather that he knew how to take MJK's heart in such a specialised and advanced manner (relatively) because he had cut lots of women up before.

Let's also consider 2 keys points...


Similar to Chapman and Stride; Eddowes was virtually decapitated. That perhaps shows intent to take the head and initiate a form of dismemberment.

The Torso Killer was skilled at removing heads. The Ripper was a bumbling amateur.

[Geddy2112]

The Torso Killer was skilled at removing heads. The Ripper was a bumbling amateur.

So you are saying the Torso Killer and Jack The Ripper were two different people?

[C. F. Leon]

So you are saying the Torso Killer and Jack The Ripper were two different people?

Most people think so. Unless Someone was taking Shelley's Frankenstein as a "How-To" Guide.

[The Rookie Detective]

I would also consider the hypothetical option that the Torso killer was perhaps plural, and that there was more than one man involved, and responsible; perhaps a group of 3 to 4 men working together.

And on that basis; Jack was one of those 4 men.

Imagine if you will that the 'Torso killers' were a band...and that Jack tried out a separate solo career.



RD

[John Wheat]

I would also consider the hypothetical option that the Torso killer was perhaps plural, and that there was more than one man involved, and responsible; perhaps a group of 3 to 4 men working together.

And on that basis; Jack was one of those 4 men.

Imagine if you will that the 'Torso killers' were a band...and that Jack tried out a separate solo career.



RD

In my opinion this is a wild theory you've dreamt up. In all likelihood Jack had no part in the Torso Murders.