If you could move one non canonical victim to the canonical 5, who would you move?

[Parker_Pyne79]

And why?

[GUT]

Probably Martha.

Because I think she is most likely.

[Parker_Pyne79]

Thanks

Also, do use murder research to get newspaper articles on murders?

[John Wheat]

Definitely Tabram because I believe in all likeliness she was killed by Jack.

[Elamarna]

Mackenzie,

because her inclusion, excludes some suspects, while also possibly strengthening the case for others.

steve

[Mayerling]

I would be more inclined to Tabram due to the closeness of her murder in weeks to the canonical five than the murder of Mackenzie. Smith is too many months back, and Cole too many years ahead.

Jeff

[007]

Martha Tabram, for the reasons given above by others.

[miss marple]

Martha again for the same reasons. Also Tom Wescott has blown apart the soldier theory in Bank Holiday Murders.


Miss Marple

[Pierre]

And why?

Alice McKenzie.

Wounds produced by left-handed cut (Phillips).

It was Jack the Ripper (Monro).

Personal data sources matching.

[Abby Normal]

And why?

I would move two-Martha Tabram and McKenzie.
Main reason-skirt pushed up on both.
and various other similarities.

[Fisherman]

Tabram, most likely MacKenzie - and all the Thames torso victims.

Because I think Tabram was likely a Ripper deed, because I think MacKenzie was likely a Ripper deed - and because I think there can be no serious doubt that the Ripper and the Torso killer were one and the same.

[jerryd]

Alice McKenzie.

Wounds produced by left-handed cut (Phillips).

It was Jack the Ripper (Monro).

Personal data sources matching.

I agree and disagree.

I agree Alice McKenzie has a great possibility of being killed by the same hand as some of the other victims in this case. I disagree her killer was left handed. The evidence points more toward a right handed killer. I am surprised Dr. Phillips said the wounds were made by a left handed person. Dr. Bond also disagreed with him on that point.

[Pierre]

[QUOTE=jerryd;391945]

I agree and disagree.

I agree Alice McKenzie has a great possibility of being killed by the same hand as some of the other victims in this case.

I disagree her killer was left handed. The evidence points more toward a right handed killer.


I am surprised Dr. Phillips said the wounds were made by a left handed person.

Dr. Bond also disagreed with him on that point.

Hi Jerry,

Yes, they did disagree with eachother on the issue of the handedness of the killer.

And that is a very important thing.

There was a reason for it.

Regards, Pierre

[jerryd]

[QUOTE=Pierre;391989]

Hi Jerry,

Yes, they did disagree with eachother on the issue of the handedness of the killer.

And that is a very important thing.

There was a reason for it.

Regards, Pierre

I'm guessing you say it it was a conspiracy to cover up for a particular police official. I simply say the evidence points to a right handed killer.

So who was lying? Bond or Phillips, according to your hypothesis?