Berner Street: No Plot, No Mystery

[c.d.]

It’s the good thing about the forum….someone will know or someone will find the relevant info.

Or someone will simply pull something out of their ass.

c.d.

[Herlock Sholmes]

It’s the good thing about the forum….someone will know or someone will find the relevant info.

Or someone will simply pull something out of their ass.

c.d.

I was thinking it….you said it

[Fiver]

There has in the past been some inconclusive discussion on this matter. Some think that "came down to see what was the matter" referred to him coming down from his home, whereas others think he meant he came down from upstairs in the club. There was a lecture that night on why jews should be socialists and I believe attendance was not restricted to club members.

That makes Michael's theory even more ludicrous. It would mean that non-club members were present while the club members plotted to change the time.

[Herlock Sholmes]

That makes Michael's theory even more ludicrous. It would mean that non-club members were present while the club members plotted to change the time.

And not only didn’t he manage to tell Kozebrodsky (who was actually with him!) about the ‘real’ discovery time, he forgot to tell Heschberg (whether a member or not) but he also brought a stranger, Spooner, with him. Did he think that the police wouldn’t bother interviewing him thus spilling the beans. As I’ve said since the beginning Fiver, the plot theory is a complete none starter.