It was Lechmere.

[Mike J. G.]

I can imagine "Fisherman" on his way back from wherever, thinking..
"I wonder how me Lechmere thingy is going on casebook"................

lol

"Ooooo, bugger!"

Initiating Damage-Control in 5, 4, 3, 2...

[Rainbow]

That was because of the 'From Hell' letter,

If it was authentic, which I am still researching this, that explains the missing heart from Kelly..

I studied some of Lechmere's hand writings, I saw some similarities, but that is only in my ongoing research..


Rainbow°

[Pierre]

Bekieve me Pierre, I see the position of Fisherman is more neutral and flexible than mine in the case of Lechmere

Rainbow°

How interesting. Rainbow. In another thread you said you think that the killer ate Kelly´s heart. Do you think that Lechmere did that? If so, why?

Cheers, Pierre

[Rainbow]

Hi Rainbow,

No, you have nothing to sell. But you have something to buy.

And since you have bought the idea about Lechmere being Jack the Ripper, you are convinced.

The one who has convinced you is Fisherman.

He has something to sell.

Cheers, Pierre

Believe me Pierre, I see the position of Fisherman is more neutral and flexible than mine in the case of Lechmere


Rainbow°

[Rainbow]

You answer this

How long do expect to detect breathing movements in chest after the head was almost severed from the body?!

I am sure if I said this cup of tea is sweet, you are going to ask for a medical proof for it... it is just talking for the hell of talking ...

Rainbow°

[Elamarna]

Of course, you have the right to.

I personaly believe, that there was the last movement of breathing in her chest when Paul was there.

That leaves no space in my mind, (even more than the bleeding evidence) to any other killer than Lechmere,

I am happily convinced, and I don't want to convince anyone.

I have nothing to sell.

Rainbow°

Neither do most of us.

The question is not really was she breathing but why you think that points to Lechmere, what medical/scientific data are you basing this on?


Steve

[Pierre]

Of course, you have the right to.

I personaly believe, that there was the last movement of breathing in her chest when Paul was there.

That leaves no space in my mind, (even more than the bleeding evidence) to any other killer than Lechmere,

I am happily convinced, and I don't want to convince anyone.

I have nothing to sell.

Rainbow°

Hi Rainbow,

No, you have nothing to sell. But you have something to buy.

And since you have bought the idea about Lechmere being Jack the Ripper, you are convinced.

The one who has convinced you is Fisherman.

He has something to sell.

Cheers, Pierre

[Pierre]

Wishful thinking my friend. The case gets weaker not stronger.

Steve

The only social situation in 2017 where an hypothesis about Lechmere having been Jack the Ripper would be viewed as a strong case is the social situation where all the other cases are very weak.

Pierre

[Rainbow]

Of course, you have the right to.

I personaly believe, that there was the last movement of breathing in her chest when Paul was there.

That leaves no space in my mind, (even more than the bleeding evidence) to any other killer than Lechmere,

I am happily convinced, and I don't want to convince anyone.

I have nothing to sell.

Rainbow°

[Elamarna]

That Lechmere needs a damn good lawyer now.

His case is losing...

Rainbow°

Wishful thinking my friend. The case gets weaker not stronger.


Steve

[Elamarna]

That is your view you are entitled to it. It does of course cause considerable damage to the blood flow theory. But of course it does not function as a working hypothesis to start with anyway.


Steve

It is highly unlikely that the abdomen wounds would have caused the blood pressure to drop as fast as you suggest. Details provide by poster Kjab3112 thread blood oozing post #622 gives details. He is a medic so I tend to accept his view on this over non experts


Steve

[Rainbow]

That Lechmere needs a damn good lawyer now.

His case is losing...

Rainbow°

[Elamarna]

Its is based on logic

How long do you expect to have breath movements of the chest ?

huh ?!

Rainbow°

Ah so not based on any actual knowledge of the subject. It's not logic by the way it's guess work..

When there is a blockage to the upper end of the windpipe the emergency procedure is to open the windpipe lower down to the outside atmosphere. This allow breathing to continue. The major issue with the wounds Nichols had is that the bleeding may in all probability caused the windpipe to become blocked with blood. It would not in my understanding in itself stop breathing.

And of course you forget that Paul was very uncertain if he detected breathing at all.


Steve

[Rainbow]

Its is based on logic

How long do you expect to have breath movements of the chest ?

huh ?!

Rainbow°

[Elamarna]

and I think, I started to accept the report that the throat cut happened after.

She was unconscious, the heart puls was weak, and when Lechmere noticed Paul coming, he sliced her throat.

Thats maybe why Paul didn't spot directly the bleeding, but he detected the remaining and the last movement of her chest..


Rainbow°

That is your view you are entitled to it. It does of course cause considerable damage to the blood flow theory. But of course it does not function as a working hypothesis to start with anyway.


Steve