Originally posted by Pontius2000
View Post
I think it's obvious that the whole case against Kosminski was dreamed up.
Anderson was known to be a fantasist.
Swanson's notes and marginalia are wrong in almost every detail.
The whole idea of a Jewish witness refusing to testify against a fellow Jew and that that caused the case against Kosminski to collapse is unbelievable.
If a Jewish witness had been unwilling to testify against a fellow Jew, then he wouldn't have gone to the police in the first place!
Moreover, it is far fetched that the conviction of the Whitechapel Murderer would have depended upon an eyewitness testifying in court!
Finally, there is no credible candidate for the claimed witness because Lawende would have been willing to testify, as he later did for the prosecution in the murder trial of a fellow Jew, but in any case said he would not be able to recognise the man if he saw him again. And Schwarz did not in fact see the murderer; he saw someone else!
There are certain things about Kosminski that rule him out as a serious suspect and they are never mentioned by the people who say he was the murderer.
The murderer was extremely quick and streetwise.
He obviously knew the police officers' beats off by heart and if he was somewhere near an officer's beat, he did not approach a woman until the officer had passed, timing everything so that he could get away before the officer's return.
He obviously had experience of cutting up animals and was able to work incredibly quickly.
Like some other psychopaths, he obviously had social skills and knew how to persuade a prostitute to go with him.
Kosminski was an imbecilic schizophrenic who was obviously completely unworldly and slow-witted, is not actually known ever to have associated with prostitutes, had never been a butcher or slaughterer, and couldn't speak English.
Do you think he could have chatted up Catherine Eddowes in English, persuaded her to go with him - a man who used to eat from the gutter - into a dark area of a square, murdered and mutilated her, cut off her apron and evaded capture by the police, all in the space of about 10 minutes?
Leave a comment: