If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Yeah, as you know, Uncle, nearly all the general histories devote a chapter, or at least a section, to Chapman. Offhand I can't think of another author who focusses on Chapman to the extent that Gordon does, but I'll have a look through my bookshelves when I get home.
The story that has kicked around here for some time is that Sugden's publisher really wanted him to name a suspect. Sugden wasn't keen on the idea because he thought there wasn't enough evidence against anyone. In the end, what he said was that Chapman was the least unlikely of all the named suspects. Don't know if that's true or not, but that's the story.
I've checked all my non-fiction books (and I've got most of them) and I can't find anyone who centres on Chapman except Gordon.
Gordon's books aren't that bad, Iago, in fact he writes with a certain panache that I rather admire. It's just that he seems to accuse Chapman of every unsolved murder in London during the period in question. The body count gets up to about 20, as I recall. It becomes a bit laughable as he tries to stretch his point.
You put too great a strain on my memory, Uncle. Gordon's theory is outlined in his Alias JtR: Beyond the Usual Whitechapel Suspects which came out in 2001, and which I'm not about to re-read. He includes the canonicals, the non-canonicals, the Pinchin Street and Whitehall torsos, Carrie Brown and Elizabeth Senior, Chapman's poisoning victims...the list goes on and on.
Gordon believes that Chapman murdered, or at least attacked: Margaret Hames (who was actually attacked by a group of men), both Annie Millwood and Ada Wilson, Martha Tabram, the “canonical five,” Susan Ward (who has been confused with the unnamed victim of a reported attack. Ward actually fell on some glass and cut herself), Rose Mylett, Alice McKenzie and Francis Coles, the five torso victims, the supposed US victims – Carrie Brown, Hannah Robinson, Elizabeth Senior and Hester Mary Anderson (even though Chapman wasn’t in the US when Brown and Anderson were killed) – the three Borough Poisoning victims and, perhaps, a Polish barber surgeon named Severin Klosowski whose identity, Gordon speculates with no real evidence, Chapman may have assumed after murdering him. That makes 22 murder victims.
Wolf, thanks for the info regarding Brown. I always thought Chapman had moved to the US in early 1891 and was there for the Brown murder. Thanks for that.
Best regards,
Adam
"They assumed Kelly was the last... they assumed wrong" - Me
Just listening to Mr Gordons rippercast on George Chapman,is his theory about 'Jack' changing his appearance with hair from the barbers(he worked in) discussed in the book,also the Liz Stride being a wrong hit?
I maybe well off line here,but just cant have that,any views? Thanks
Comment