Macnaghten as a suspect

[Captain Hook]

Salut David,

Do you really think Strong is Sophie Herfort?

Amitiès,
Crochet

[DVV]

Poor strong,
go take fresh air and piss in your own trousers.
If you are not a coward yourself why don't you come here with your genuine name, Sophie Herfort, instead of lying and saying "I'm a reader..."

[Captain Hook]

no one here speaks french

Strong mon vieux, tu te trompes. Il'y a des gens ici qui parlent français et le comprennent encore mieux mais qui se sont rendu compte tout de suite que tu es en train de te moquer de tout le monde avec ton imitation d'un petit "frog" qui masssacre l'anglais. Je suis sûr que tu ne vas pas t'attarder dans ce forum parce que tu n'es pas serieux.

À plus
Capitaine Crochet

[Dan Norder]

The tarp was found under the tag ! Even a donkey knows that !

There was no tarp. Sophie misread the witness testimony. Cross at first thought Nichols' body was a tarp because it was too dark to see properly, but it was really a dead body. For as much as you rant here about people not being able to read French, she can't read English well enough to get basic facts about the case straight.

I don't waste my time with frustrated retired people full of hatred against brillant and young foreigners !

Retired people? What are you even talking about? And, I'm sorry, but it's not "brilliant" to try to blame a bunch of murders on a police official. In fact, it's about the most boneheaded thing anyone could do.

But then every time Sophie or one of her true believers posts here (assuming there are any and it's not just her posting under an alias... she used to do that to try to pretend she had supporters) it's always just filled with the most ridiculous claims and insults against the world. But then I guess you'd have to be crazy to think Sophie is brilliant.

[STRONG]

Many Thanks Roy !

Hi Strong. And welcome to the discussion. You have had a pretty rough reception here, but then you come on a lttle strong.

I don't speak French either. Probably the closest I come to it is every once a while go on down to New Orleans, Louisiana, play some roulette and drink a concoction called a Hurricane, then I might let out a Aaaa-iieee, which is Cajun for "we gonna party all night long!"



I'll tell you what. When Ms. Herfort's book is translated into English and stocked in the public library here, I will be the first one to check it out and read the entire work.

And again, Strong, welcome to the discussion. If I might give you a little hint, simply moderate your enthusiam just a tad, and I think you will find that are a lot of really good people here. Not the zenophobic kind, but very willing to consider new ideas.

Roy

Thank you Roy. Your support is a good thing and I'm sure Herfort's theory will be at New Orleans as soon as possible.
According to me, I'm convinced at 100 % but each person have the right to share or not her conviction but before to judge a fact, all the elements must be known. And the problem is the following : no one here speaks french but everybody here pretends to know all about her work. That's the main pbm. But Thank you again for your advice ! Bonjour aux cajuns !

Have a good night Roy !


She Strong.

[STRONG]

Xenophob Again !

The French...man,they're a funny race.
They fight with their feet and....and
...they waste our time and their own with zees incredible theories of seeing ze ghosts of victims on ze streets and fitting up suspects out of ze air ! Who's next? Madame Helena Covell Blavatsky ? Mon Dieu !!!!!!
_____________________________________

IT'S BECAUSE OF THESE XENOPHOB PEOPLE THAT WARS DO EXIST !
Can you repeat your insult in front of a french person without to piss in your trousers, please ? According to me, I don't believe in gosts and I don't think that Sophie does ! Don't tell rubbishes bigger than your ass !

YOU XENOPHOBIAN DIMWIT !

[Roy Corduroy]

Hi Strong. And welcome to the discussion. You have had a pretty rough reception here, but then you come on a lttle strong.

I don't speak French either. Probably the closest I come to it is every once a while go on down to New Orleans, Louisiana, play some roulette and drink a concoction called a Hurricane, then I might let out a Aaaa-iieee, which is Cajun for "we gonna party all night long!"



I'll tell you what. When Ms. Herfort's book is translated into English and stocked in the public library here, I will be the first one to check it out and read the entire work.

And again, Strong, welcome to the discussion. If I might give you a little hint, simply moderate your enthusiam just a tad, and I think you will find that are a lot of really good people here. Not the zenophobic kind, but very willing to consider new ideas.

Roy

[STRONG]

Why don't you just shut your mouth ? IF YOU DO IGNORE THE HERFORT'S THEORY !

You don't seem to have a high opinion of this site Strong. Makes me wonder if you joined just for arguments sake. I am new, like yourself, but you are not going very far to gain friends here....

ARE YOU HERE TO GAIN FRIENDS ? OH POOR ! DON'T MAKE YOUR OWN CASE A GENERALITY, PLEASE AND ...
OPEN WIDELY YOUR EARS, DONKEY :

ARGUMENTS SHOULD BE THE ONLY WAY TO RECOGNIZE AN OPINION... BUT FROM THE START ALL KIND OF RUBBISHES ARE SAID ABOUT A THEORY THAT NO ONE IS ABLE TO READ IN FRENCH ON THIS WEBSITE !

The best you have is to shut your mouth if you ignore all about the research proposed by Sophie Herfort !
I DON'T WANT TO HAVE TO TELL YOU AGAIN ! (MESSAGE FOR ALL) !

She Strong (reader and sympathiser )

[STRONG]

Rubbishes & Nonsense

Don't you know about Indian shoes in Hanbury Street? The double life of John Pizer? The tarpaulin in Buck's Row? And what about the magical powers of Commissioner Warren? Hmmm?
Hello Sophie, it's Jack, and I wish you were around...
Love is all, but...
Sorry for my broken english,
David (aka Fu Manchu)

ALL THESE RUBBISHES ARE NOT IN THE BOOK OF SOPHIE HERFORT !
THESE WORDS ARE WRITTEN BY A STUPID DETRACTOR, MENTALLY ILL !

If you're enough stupid to believe that !

[STRONG]

Unqualified People Here !

And if some person trying to treat her as a genius while ignoring that she can't get basic facts about the case right (she thinks Polly Nichols' body was found under a tarp -- 'nuff said).

She never told such a rubbish ! (Polly Nichols Pfff ! The tarp was found under the tag ! Even a donkey knows that ! ) S. Herfort knows perfectly her subject that's why she disturbs few tiny brains...

EXHIBITED in museum = ACCREDITED in world

BANISHED from a nazi website = WELL DONE for her ! WELL DONE !

The experts who work with them are very important (interpol, ex commissioner of Paris and expert criminologist, qualified by the european parliament !) Do you know what does it mean ? I don't waste my time with frustrated retired people full of hatred against brillant and young foreigners !

END OF THIS CHAPTER ! You can tell all what you want, nothing's true about her work. You don't speak french !

I SEE NO ONE ARGUMENT HERE... ONLY XENOPHOBIA !

All you don't speak french and a great average of you are worther than the KKK itself ! Racists and unable to speak the language they badly criticize ! What a cocktail of idiots !

[Howard Brown]

The French...man,they're a funny race.
They fight with their feet and....and
...they waste our time and their own with zees incredible theories of seeing ze ghosts of victims on ze streets and fitting up suspects out of ze air ! Who's next? Madame Helena Covell Blavatsky ? Mon Dieu !!!!!!
_____________________________________

2. Her work obtains a certain public credibility (Museum in Docklands of London, french interviews TV radios, press),--Strong

Being a celebrity on zee French t.v. is like bragging about being the leper with the most fingers.

I have a mystery that you French can try and figure out...if you would,sie vous plais and all that:

When was the War of 1812?

[Dan Norder]

So, what the serious searchers are expecting from persons without qualifications like you ? Who are you ? EXPERTS ? CRIMINOLOGISTS ?

I'm sorry, but Sophie has far less qualifications to be writing a book about the Ripper than the vast majority of the people on this message board, and the people who are experts and criminologists do not take her book at all seriously.

The critics gave her a rough ride on Casebook but the real specialists (Experts) accept her theory as a fact, you like it or not !

Nobody accepts her theory as a fact, probably not even Sophie herself.

And if some person trying to treat her as a genius while ignoring that she can't get basic facts about the case right (she thinks Polly Nichols' body was found under a tarp -- 'nuff said) has a problem with that, you certainly aren't going to convince anyone you are right by merely insulting everyone here.

[Uncle Jack]

You don't seem to have a high opinion of this site Strong. Makes me wonder if you joined just for arguments sake. I am new, like yourself, but you are not going very far to gain friends here....

[STRONG]

Do they list Police Officers during the period?

Inspector Frederick Bailey Deeming?

Chief Inspector Robert D'Onston Stephenson?

I don't remember but you can visit the museum, Mike.
1 year : 1 suspect. (2007 : Melville Macnaghten)
You'll have an idea, different of what can be said HERE !


S. Strong

[STRONG]

And yet, if it was published in an English translation, how many of us would buy it? Hands up, please...

B. (with hand raised, but only in a bargain bin or cheap online)

Many people except idiots !


"She Strong"