The BIG Poll

[Abby Normal]

Fair enough, Herlock, although I thought you responded to some of Richard's lengthy posts with a terse one-liner about them being more 'nonsense' created by AI. If there has been any direct discussion between the two of you since then I think I must have missed it. I've seen him responding directly to various other posters who have issues with his stated facts and reasoning, so why do you suppose he has not extended the same courtesy to you?

Love,

Caz
X

because he knows hes wrong and herlocks right?

[Enigma]

18 voters so far. I was hoping for more but obviously everyone is free to vote or not. I said November 25 as the final day but if no one else is going to vote I’ll give it another week.

There are 99 active members, so 18% of us have voted which is probably about on par with previous polls.

[Barnaby]

1. Jacob Levy
2. Aaron Kosminski
3. Nathan Kaminski/David Cohen
4. Charles Lechmere
5. James Kelly
6. Hyam Hyams
7. Francis Thompson

[Herlock Sholmes]

1. Jacob Levy
2. Aaron Kosminski
3. Nathan Kaminski/David Cohen
4. Charles Lechmere
5. James Kelly
6. Hyam Hyams
7. Francis Thompson

Cheers Barnaby

[Herlock Sholmes]

Leather Apron (not Pizer)

Sorry Scott, I missed this. Now added.

[Herlock Sholmes]

We have had 20 posters voting.


Results


1. Bury - 69
2. Anderson’s suspect (generic) - 49
3. Kelly - 49
4. Levy - 33
5. Cutbush - 31
6. Chapman - 31
7. Druitt - 18
8. Cohen - 15
9. Kosminski - 13
10. Lawende’s man - 13
11. BS man - 11
12. Hutchinson - 10
13. Blotchy man - 8
14. The Bethnal Green Botherer - 8
15. Kosminski (not Aaron) - 7
16. Leather Apron (not Pizer) - 7
17. Pipeman - 7
18. Gull - 7
19. Tomkins - 6
20. GCS Lechmere - 6
21. Bachert - 6
22. Sagar’s suspect - 6
23. Hyams - 6
24. Henry Cox’s suspect - 5
25. Wentworth Bell-Smith - 5
26. Hanslope - 5
27. Astrakhan man - 5
28. Sarah Lewis’s man (someone other than Hutchinson)
29. Richardson - 4
30. Deeming - 4
31. Wainwright - 4
32. Lechmere - 4
33. Buckley - 3
34. Barnett - 3
35. Mann - 3
36. One of the gang that attacked Emma Smith - 3
37. Hardiman - 3
38. Le Grand - 3
39. Silverman - 3
40. An unnamed client of Mary Kelly’s - 2
41. Thompson - 3
42. Grainger - 1
43. Henry Maxwell - 1
44. R. O’D. Stephenson - 1
45. Deeming - 1
46. Swyer - 1
47. Moross - 1
48. Butcher/Horse Slaughterer - 1


——————————————————


With Anderson’s suspects combined as one


1. Anderson’s suspect (generic) - 84
2. Bury - 69
3. Kelly - 49
4. Levy - 33
5. Cutbush - 31
6. Chapman - 31
7. Druitt - 18
8. Lawende’s man - 13
9. BS man - 11
10. Hutchinson - 10
11. Blotchy man - 8
12. The Bethnal Green Botherer - 8
13. Leather Apron (not Pizer) - 7
14. Pipeman - 7
15. Gull - 7
16. Tomkins - 6
17. GCS Lechmere - 6
18. Bachert - 6
19. Sagar’s suspect - 6
20. Hyams - 6
21. Henry Cox’s suspect - 5
22. Wentworth Bell-Smith - 5
23. Hanslope - 5
24. Astrakhan man - 5
25. Sarah Lewis’s man (someone other than Hutchinson)
26. Richardson - 4
27. Deeming - 4
28. Wainwright - 4
29. Lechmere - 4
30. Buckley - 3
31. Barnett - 3
32. Mann - 3
33. One of the gang that attacked Emma Smith - 3
34. Hardiman - 3
35. Le Grand - 3
36. Silverman - 3
37. An unnamed client of Mary Kelly’s - 2
38. Thompson - 3
39. Grainger - 1
40. Henry Maxwell - 1
41. R. O’D. Stephenson - 1
42. Deeming - 1
43. Swyer - 1
44. Moross - 1
45. Butcher/ Horse Slaughterer - 1


———————————————————-


The top twenty from the poll with the scores added from Rating the Suspects Thread



1. Bury - 79
2. Kelly - 62
3. Anderson’s suspect (generic) - 57
4. Chapman - 44
5. Levy - 39
6. Cutbush - 31
7. Druitt - 24
8. Cohen - 23
9. Kosminski - 21
10. Lawende’s man - 13
11. GCS Lechmere - 13
12. BS man - 11
13. Gull - 11
14. Hutchinson - 10
15. Blotchy man - 8
16. The Bethnal Green Botherer - 8
17. Kosminski (not Aaron) - 7
18. Leather Apron (not Pizer) - 7
19. Pipeman - 7
20. Tomkins - 6

[Pcdunn]

Interesting stats, Herlock. I continue to see names new to me, or ones I need to refresh myself about.

[Herlock Sholmes]

Interesting stats, Herlock. I continue to see names new to me, or ones I need to refresh myself about.

There are definitely some new/lesser known suspects on there, largely thanks to The Rookie Detective’

This is about Swyer.

https://forum.casebook.org/forum/rip...oviso#post6806

Silverman had a Chandler’s shop in Fashion Street I believe and ended up insane but I know nothing more at this point.

I don’t know who Moross is I’m afraid. I’ll have to find out though.

Some info on Hanslope here from RD

https://forum.casebook.org/forum/rip...488#post861488

[Lewis C]

Hi Herlock,

Deeming is listed twice. On the top poll, he's at #30 and #45. On the 2nd poll, he's at #27 and #42.

[Herlock Sholmes]

Hi Herlock,

Deeming is listed twice. On the top poll, he's at #30 and #45. On the 2nd poll, he's at #27 and #42.

Yes, I thought I’d add a deliberate mistake to see who is paying attention.


I also just noticed that I hadn’t put the votes on for Sarah Lewis”s man.


1. Bury - 69
2. Anderson’s suspect (generic) - 49
3. Kelly - 49
4. Levy - 33
5. Cutbush - 31
6. Chapman - 31
7. Druitt - 18
8. Cohen - 15
9. Kosminski - 13
10. Lawende’s man - 13
11. BS man - 11
12. Hutchinson - 10
13. Blotchy man - 8
14. The Bethnal Green Botherer - 8
15. Kosminski (not Aaron) - 7
16. Leather Apron (not Pizer) - 7
17. Pipeman - 7
18. Gull - 7
19. Tomkins - 6
20. GCS Lechmere - 6
21. Bachert - 6
22. Sagar’s suspect - 6
23. Hyams - 6
24. Henry Cox’s suspect - 5
25. Wentworth Bell-Smith - 5
26. Hanslope - 5
27. Astrakhan man - 5
28. Sarah Lewis’s man (someone other than Hutchinson) - 5
29. Deeming - 5
30. Richardson - 4
31. Wainwright - 4
32. Lechmere - 4
33. Buckley - 3
34. Barnett - 3
35. Mann - 3
36. One of the gang that attacked Emma Smith - 3
37. Hardiman - 3
38. Le Grand - 3
39. Silverman - 3
40. An unnamed client of Mary Kelly’s - 2
41. Thompson - 3
42. Grainger - 1
43. Henry Maxwell - 1
44. R. O’D. Stephenson - 1
45. Deeming - 1
46. Swyer - 1
47. Moross - 1
48. Butcher/Horse Slaughterer - 1


——————————————————


With Anderson’s suspects combined as one


1. Anderson’s suspect (generic) - 84
2. Bury - 69
3. Kelly - 49
4. Levy - 33
5. Cutbush - 31
6. Chapman - 31
7. Druitt - 18
8. Lawende’s man - 13
9. BS man - 11
10. Hutchinson - 10
11. Blotchy man - 8
12. The Bethnal Green Botherer - 8
13. Leather Apron (not Pizer) - 7
14. Pipeman - 7
15. Gull - 7
16. Tomkins - 6
17. GCS Lechmere - 6
18. Bachert - 6
19. Sagar’s suspect - 6
20. Hyams - 6
21. Henry Cox’s suspect - 5
22. Wentworth Bell-Smith - 5
23. Hanslope - 5
24. Astrakhan man - 5
25. Sarah Lewis’s man (someone other than Hutchinson) - 5
26. Deeming - 5
27. Richardson - 4
28. Wainwright - 4
29. Lechmere - 4
30. Buckley - 3
31. Barnett - 3
32. Mann - 3
33. One of the gang that attacked Emma Smith - 3
34. Hardiman - 3
35. Le Grand - 3
36. Silverman - 3
37. An unnamed client of Mary Kelly’s - 2
38. Thompson - 3
39. Grainger - 1
40. Henry Maxwell - 1
41. R. O’D. Stephenson - 1
42. Deeming - 1
43. Swyer - 1
44. Moross - 1
45. Butcher/ Horse Slaughterer -