The BIG Poll

[Herlock Sholmes]

Ok I’ll apologise first… I’m sorry for yet another poll but I’ve been considering this one for ages and was put off doing it. It’s a suspect poll but I wanted to do it differently and make it The BIG one.


I’m going to allow everyone up to 7 suspects. You can post as few as you want to but no more than 7. Just post them in order of preference (which I realise can be difficult if some are close) so

1. Mr X
2. Mr Y
3. Mr Z
4. Etc
5. Etc
6. Etc
7. Etc

I’ll award points.

1. 7 points
2. 6 points
3. 5 points
4. 4 points
5. 3 points
6. 2 points
7. 1 point

I’m not counting ‘as yet unnamed man’ as I’m only looking for ratings of the named suspects.

I’ll count up the votes on November 30th

Btw…this isn’t intended as a thread for debating suspects merit.

ps. I’m not going to make changes to but if someone later wants to add a suspect to the bottom of their previous list (maybe if they forget to mention them) I’ll add them.

[Herlock Sholmes]

I’ll start.

1. Cutbush
2. Druitt
3. Bury
4. Kelly
5. Kosminski/Cohen etc (basically Anderson’s suspect)