Interesting Thread Regarding Anderson's Suspect.

[Geddy2112]

A new thread has emerged over at the JTR forums - https://www.jtrforums.com/forum/pers...PyyWEfzgUDmMNA

Will be great to see how this pans out, hope it does not turn into a 'Perrie'

[Elamarna]

Can I suggest we wait until some details are provided.

Steve

[Tani]

Who is it, or is this just more fluff?

[Elamarna]

No details given no name.
Just a claim that someone new is Anderson's suspect.

[The Baron]

Swanson said Kosminski, then Kosminski it is. He had direct knowledge, he wrote it down, and that settles it. No amount of speculation, theories, or so called new evidence changes that. Swanson knew the truth, and his word stands above all. Others can debate all they want, it doesn’t matter. Swanson said Kosminski, then Kosminski it is. End of it.



The Baron

[Geddy2112]

Swanson said Kosminski, then Kosminski it is. End of it.

Which Kosminski?

[Elamarna]

Which Kosminski?

In this context it doesn't matter Geddy, as the suggestion is that the suspect had a completely different name.

Details are still awaited.

Steve

[Lewis C]

Swanson said Kosminski, then Kosminski it is. He had direct knowledge, he wrote it down, and that settles it. No amount of speculation, theories, or so called new evidence changes that. Swanson knew the truth, and his word stands above all. Others can debate all they want, it doesn’t matter. Swanson said Kosminski, then Kosminski it is. End of it.



The Baron

One could just as easily say that if Swanson said that the suspect died shortly after being sent to Colney Hatch, then that's the way it is.

[Geddy2112]

In this context it doesn't matter Geddy, as the suggestion is that the suspect had a completely different name. Details are still awaited.

Hi Steve, was just wondering if the Baron thought it was Aaron or A.N. Otherski so to speak. I hope Rookie D pulls something out of the bag with this one. I know he states it's not a naming the Ripper exercise but it's surely exciting none the less. I believe, correct me if I'm wrong you like 'Anderson's Suspect' which may or may not be Aaron so I'm sure you are waiting with baited breath. In fact you should already know. If I wanted anything checking Ripper wise I'd be dropping you a line.

Hope it all comes good for the 'Anderson's Suspect' Team.

[Trevor Marriott]

One could just as easily say that if Swanson said that the suspect died shortly after being sent to Colney Hatch, then that's the way it is.

Swansons memo is unsafe to rely on in any event.

Magnaghten was Swanson's immediate superior and Anderson was superior to both yet neither mention anything about Kosminski and this alleged ID parade where Kosminski was supposedly identified. In fact, none of the other officers directly involved in the investigation make any mention of what Swanson describes in his memo regarding Kosminski.

https://www.trevormarriott.co.uk

[The Baron]

Swanson's notes are the ultimate, indisputable foundation of truth, untouchable, irrefutable, and the closest thing to absolute authority on anything Jack the Ripper related. To doubt them is to embrace ignorance, to challenge them is to wage war against historical certainty itself.



The Baron

[c.d.]

I hope Rookie D pulls something out of the bag with this one.

Let's hope that is where he pulls it from.

c.d.

[New Ford Shunt]

Swanson's notes are the ultimate, indisputable foundation of truth, untouchable, irrefutable, and the closest thing to absolute authority on anything Jack the Ripper related. To doubt them is to embrace ignorance, to challenge them is to wage war against historical certainty itself.



The Baron

Yet you're equally as pertinacious when you comment on Lechmere....

[Elamarna]

Swansons memo is unsafe to rely on in any event.

Magnaghten was Swanson's immediate superior and Anderson was superior to both yet neither mention anything about Kosminski and this alleged ID parade where Kosminski was supposedly identified. In fact, none of the other officers directly involved in the investigation make any mention of what Swanson describes in his memo regarding Kosminski.

www.trevormarriott.co.uk

Just your opinion tgat it's unsafe. Same old.

[Elamarna]

I will just repeat, until we have details about this new suggestion, it's hard to debate if it as merit or not