BSM & Sailor Man : one and the same ?

[Bridewell]

It was 50/50 when I voted - so no pressure! On balance I think there is enough similarity to say that BS Man & Lawende's man could well be one and the same and that's the way I've voted. Agree also that both Marshall and Smith could be describing the same individual.

I guess if you think there was a Double Event (same killer) you see the similarities, but if you favour a different killer for Stride you notice the differences.

[Abby Normal]

I`d go so far as to say BS Man, Sailor Man and Marshall`s Man were all the one and the same.

Absolutely" I would go so far as to possibly include PC smiths man also and call them all Peaked Cap man, as I have argued in the past.

[Jonathan H]

It is more likely Schwartz told the truth to 'The Star' and not to the police:

In the press version, the second man carried a knife -- and broadly matches the description by Lawende -- and not a pipe.

[DVV]

'Knifeman' is a better match for Jack the Sailor.

Hi Jonathan, you mean the Star's Pipeman, I presume ?

[DVV]

Hi Jon,
I'd go so far as to say I tend to agree....

Cheers

[Jon Guy]

I`d go so far as to say BS Man, Sailor Man and Marshall`s Man were all the one and the same.

[Jonathan H]

'Knifeman' is a better match for Jack the Sailor.

[DVV]

Hummm ?