Originally posted by Herlock Sholmes
View Post
It is not purely my own opinion.
He claimed that Druitt was sexually insane.
How could he possibly have known that?
He claimed that Kosminski had strong homicidal tendencies.
Asylum records disprove that.
He claimed that Ostrog was a homicidal maniac.
He was not.
He thought that Druitt was a doctor, which means he could hardly have been aware of the dismissal or the reference to it in the suicide note.
That means that he did not even know the basic facts of the case.
He claimed that Kosminski had a great hatred of prostitutes.
There is no evidence to support that, and he could not possibly have known it to be a fact, yet he stated it as a fact.
He made numerous categorical statements of fact when he could not possibly have known them to be facts.
He did not state them as opinions or suppositions or assumptions.
It is quite obvious that he is not credible.
Leave a comment: