Suspect Witnesses?

[Lewis C]

An interesting idea, Lewis and it would make sense if she wanted to distance herself from a possible return of the B.S. man. But I can't see it working out timewise. Even if she remained near the club, the entrance of her killer onto the scene is pretty tight timewise. So I can't see how your suggestion could work giving the extra time it would have taken.

c.d.

Hi c.d.,

When I say somewhere else, I don't mean that it would have needed to be far away. I'm saying that if BS Man didn't kill her, that doesn't mean that she went back to standing in the gateway. If she was even 10 feet away from standing in the gateway, then she wouldn't have been standing in the gateway. If Brown really saw Stride, and if that was after the Schwartz incident, the couple that Brown saw wasn't standing in the gateway.

[Sunny Delight]

Schwartz and his wife.


THAT'S why Schwartz went to the police.

He was essentially BS man and he knew he had been witnesed to throw his wife down onto the ground.

So he goes to the police and essentially invents BS man the drunken gentile, to try and cover that it was HE that threw his wife down on the floor.

And if that's the case, then maybe Stride and her killer were also witnesses to that assault.

Could there be a scenario whereby Stride goes over to the yard to check on the wife?

Thet is thevl catalyst for Stride going into the yard; to help Schwartz's wife who has just been assaulted by her husband.

Of course, perhaps Stride got involved and was then murdered?

Schwartz (who is BS man) runs off and the wife goes back into the club.

Or the wife could be "Yaffa"

I reckon Schwarz and his wife were both club members

Lots to hypothesise here, haha!

Or maybe, just maybe Israel Schwartz was on his way home and witnessed an assault near a social club on Berner Street. He then learned about a murder at said social club the next day so reported what he had seen to the Police, with the help of a friend who interpreted for him.

It's not that complicated.