Door outside and inside

[Pierre]

What do you think?

[MsWeatherwax]

Think of what? What is the question, or statement, or hypothesis?

[Pierre]

Think of what? What is the question, or statement, or hypothesis?

OK. What do you think about the hypothesis A = A?

[Simon Wood]

Hi Pierre,

If you are suggesting that A [right] is the back of the door A [left], then someone had obviously been moving the furniture about in Room 13.

Think about it.

Regards,

Simon

[MsWeatherwax]

It could be. It equally might not be. Personally, I think the quality of the photograph is too poor to be absolutely certain.

How is this relevant to anything?

[Elamarna]

OK. What do you think about the hypothesis A = A?

not in my view but you know that already.

Steve

[Pierre]

Hi Pierre,

If you are suggesting that A [right] is the back of the door A [left], then someone had obviously been moving the furniture about in Room 13.

Think about it.

Regards,

Simon

Sure. The coroner asked Prater "Did you hear beds or tables being pulled about?"

And they were not able to enter the room for about two hours.

The killer just barricaded the door by drawing the bed obliquely across the room. Simple.

And you can see the hinges in the photograph.

[MsWeatherwax]

You might be able to see hinges, but I personally cannot.

Again - how is this relevant in any way?

[Robert St Devil]

http://forum.casebook.org/showthread.php?t=9281

Hi Pierre.

Has it been a year already? Time flies. How did The Pail discussion go btw? Any resolution?

[GUT]

Hasn't he done all this door BS once.

[Elamarna]

Hasn't he done all this door BS once.

at least twice before


s

[Pierre]

Hasn't he done all this door BS once.

He hasnīt done the BS comparison between the specific outside and inside doorpanels before, as far as he can remember.

BS Pierre

[Elamarna]

He hasnīt done the BS comparison between the specific outside and inside doorpanels before, as far as he can remember.

BS Pierre

Pierre,

Quite right, but it is a different take on essentially the same issue, namely the bed was used as a barricade.



Steve

[Yabs]

This might be a silly question but would it be necessary to barricade the door with the bed when you have two tables and a chair at your disposal?

[MsWeatherwax]

Why would it be necessary to barricade the door with anything, when for your last four kills you didn't even have a door to barricade?

I'm not at all convinced that someone so in the grip of psychosis, or rage, or whatever you think resulted in the complete butchery of MJK would bother with things like a barricade.

Why all of a sudden is he methodical and concerned with capture, when he's been killing women in the street all Autumn, sometimes with minutes until discovery?

The Police/photographer moved the furniture, not the killer. In my completely un-academic, uninformed opinion.