Hello everyone!
Pardon me if this has been previously discussed. I was inspired by the other ongoing thread regarding the Ripper and organ-taking.
Simply put, my question is, why did JTR take the kidney?
It is generally agreed (as far as I can tell) that JTR was a killer with a specific hatred of women (or the female prostitute class), and that this is why he targeted the uterus in his organ theft. If you believe he also killed Emma Smith and Martha Tabram, this would also explain his sexual assault of Emma and his targeting of Martha's groin.
The point was made in the other thread, as well as in other places, that accessing Catherine Eddowes' kidney must have been very difficult, especially given that she was lying on her back. I think it's reasonable to assume that, after targeting and cutting out her uterus, he then targeted a/the kidney specifically. Why else would he just "keep digging" (pardon the metaphor) for no reason, in the dark, with the possibility of getting caught at any moment?
Does anybody know if the kidney had a particular symbolism at this point in LVP/English culture? I'm thinking, for example, of how some cultures have thought of emotions as originating in the stomach or liver. Did it have a specific association with women? Would it have had a cultural message that we've now lost?
Of course, he might have just done it for fun, out of curiosity or opportunism. Or, if you believe the "From Hell" letter, to eat it. But I was curious about this possibility
Pardon me if this has been previously discussed. I was inspired by the other ongoing thread regarding the Ripper and organ-taking.
Simply put, my question is, why did JTR take the kidney?
It is generally agreed (as far as I can tell) that JTR was a killer with a specific hatred of women (or the female prostitute class), and that this is why he targeted the uterus in his organ theft. If you believe he also killed Emma Smith and Martha Tabram, this would also explain his sexual assault of Emma and his targeting of Martha's groin.
The point was made in the other thread, as well as in other places, that accessing Catherine Eddowes' kidney must have been very difficult, especially given that she was lying on her back. I think it's reasonable to assume that, after targeting and cutting out her uterus, he then targeted a/the kidney specifically. Why else would he just "keep digging" (pardon the metaphor) for no reason, in the dark, with the possibility of getting caught at any moment?
Does anybody know if the kidney had a particular symbolism at this point in LVP/English culture? I'm thinking, for example, of how some cultures have thought of emotions as originating in the stomach or liver. Did it have a specific association with women? Would it have had a cultural message that we've now lost?
Of course, he might have just done it for fun, out of curiosity or opportunism. Or, if you believe the "From Hell" letter, to eat it. But I was curious about this possibility

Comment